Get the Adam Clery Football Column. A newsletter that unpacks the absurdities and oddities of the beautiful game
There’s something peculiar about the rhythm of a football season, isn’t there? One moment you’re riding high, the narrative firmly in your favor, and the next you’re fielding questions about whether your dynasty is crumbling. Manchester City, that relentless machine of modern football, finds itself in an interesting position as they prepare to face Aston Villa at Villa Park – a venue that has become something of a bogey ground for Pep Guardiola’s typically dominant side.
The Catalan manager faced the media on Friday with news that will concern City fans but surprise absolutely nobody who has been paying attention: Rodri remains sidelined. The Spanish midfielder, arguably the most important cog in City’s well-oiled machine, continues to be unavailable following an injury sustained during the 1-0 victory over Brentford at the beginning of October. It’s the kind of injury situation that reveals just how finely balanced even the most expensively assembled squads can be.
The Rodri-Shaped Hole in City’s Midfield
“The guys who were not able [to play] against Villarreal are still not ready,” Guardiola admitted during his pre-match press conference, his typically measured tone betraying little of what must be genuine concern about his team’s engine room. The 29-year-old midfielder has been absent for two matches now – against Everton in the Premier League and Villarreal in the Champions League – and Guardiola offered no concrete timescale for his recovery. In the world of modern football management, where every word is parsed for meaning and subtext, this silence speaks volumes.
Rodri’s importance to Manchester City cannot be overstated. He’s not just a player; he’s the metronome that sets City’s tempo, the defensive shield that allows their attacking players to operate with freedom, and the positional intelligence that makes their press so suffocating. When he’s absent, City don’t just lose a midfielder – they lose their structural integrity, their rhythm, their very identity in many ways.
The fascinating thing about truly world-class defensive midfielders is that their absence is often felt more acutely than that of goalscorers or creative players. Goals are tangible, assists are measurable, but what Rodri does? That’s the dark matter of football – invisible to the casual observer but absolutely fundamental to how the universe operates.
Into this breach has stepped Nico Gonzalez, tasked with the unenviable job of replacing the irreplaceable. The young midfielder has been deployed in that anchor role at the base of City’s midfield, attempting to replicate what Rodri does with such apparent ease. But against Villarreal, Gonzalez was substituted on the hour mark, replaced by Mateo Kovacic, and now his availability for the Villa clash hangs in the balance.
“I didn’t see the doctors, we’ll see today and tomorrow how he feels,” Guardiola explained when asked about Gonzalez’s fitness. “It was something with his feet.” The vagueness is typical of injury updates in modern football, where managers play their cards close to their chest, unwilling to give opponents any advantage or to make promises they might not be able to keep.
Watching Gonzalez hobble off the pitch during the Villarreal match would have sent a chill through the City hierarchy. Here was their backup to the backup plan, potentially compromised. It’s moments like these that expose the fragility beneath even the most robust squad building. You can have all the money in the world, all the scouting networks, all the tactical acumen, but injuries are the great equalizer in football – they respect neither reputation nor bank balance.
The Title Race Narrative: A Study in Premature Conclusions
What makes this injury situation particularly intriguing is the broader context of the Premier League title race. City have won five of their eight league matches so far and, coupled with Liverpool’s recent dip in form, have climbed to second in the table, just three points behind Arsenal. Suddenly, the narrative has shifted. Where once the conversation was about whether City could keep pace, now they’re being touted as favorites to reel in the Gunners.
Guardiola, however, remains refreshingly skeptical about such early-season pronouncements. When asked if City are now the favorites to challenge Arsenal for the title, his response was deliciously dismissive of punditry’s rush to judgment.
“In the first two, three games we were done and now it looks like Liverpool are done,” Guardiola observed with what one imagines was a wry smile. “I’ll tell you that we will back. I’ve said many times that the pundits, the specialists, the former footballers know what’s going to happen after five games, I’m not able to do that.”
It’s a masterclass in perspective, this response. Guardiola has been in the game long enough to know that football seasons are marathons, not sprints, and that the breathless declarations that characterize modern football coverage often age poorly. Remember when City were supposedly finished after losing to Wolves in the opening weeks of the 2022-23 season? They went on to win the treble.
“10, 15 games to know what’s going on,” Guardiola continued. “Liverpool and Arsenal are there, someone else will be there and hopefully we can be there.” It’s a statement that simultaneously acknowledges the competition, refuses to concede any psychological advantage, and maintains the humility that has become a trademark of his public persona, even as his teams dominate domestically and continually challenge in Europe.
The truth is that the Premier League title race is far too close and far too early to call. Arsenal have been impressive, certainly, but they’ve also shown vulnerability. Liverpool, despite their recent stumble, possess enough quality to go on a run that could propel them back into contention. And City? Well, City are City – a team that has demonstrated time and again that they can flip a switch and become nearly unstoppable when the stakes are highest.
Villa Park: Where City’s Dominance Goes to Die
But before any grand title proclamations can be made, City must navigate what Guardiola himself has identified as “one of the toughest away games we’ll have all season.” The statistics make for uncomfortable reading if you’re a City fan: they haven’t won at Villa Park since December 2021, suffering two defeats and a draw in their last three visits to the Birmingham ground.
“They were much better than us at the two fixtures we played at Villa Park,” Guardiola admitted with characteristic honesty about City’s upcoming opponents. It’s not often you hear Guardiola concede tactical inferiority, which makes the admission all the more striking. Villa, under Unai Emery, have become the kind of well-drilled, tactically sophisticated side that can exploit even the smallest weaknesses in supposedly superior opponents.
“Hopefully it will be different on Sunday,” Guardiola added, before launching into an effusive assessment of Emery and his team. “The admiration I have for Unai [Emery] is so high, consistent and well-prepared.”
This isn’t just polite pre-match diplomacy. Guardiola genuinely respects what Emery has built at Villa Park. The Spanish connection between the two managers goes deeper than nationality – they share a philosophical approach to the game, an obsession with detail, and a belief in tactical preparation that borders on the fanatical.
Emery’s Villa: A Complete Team
Guardiola’s breakdown of Villa’s strengths reads like a scouting report, but one delivered with genuine appreciation: “Defensively really good, set-pieces also and after that they’ve improved a lot over the last years. With the keeper they have it’s difficult to control the pressing. They bring a lot of players in the middle, the connection is really good, they break the lines and when that happens they are so, so quick.”
Let’s unpack this assessment because it reveals everything about why Villa have become such a formidable opponent. Defensively solid – that’s the foundation of any good team, and Emery has instilled an organizational discipline that makes Villa incredibly difficult to break down. Set-pieces – often the mark of a well-coached team, and an area where Villa have become particularly dangerous, turning dead-ball situations into genuine scoring opportunities with regularity.
The mention of their goalkeeper is particularly interesting. Emiliano Martínez has become one of the Premier League’s elite shot-stoppers, but his distribution and comfort in possession make him a vital part of Villa’s build-up play. When a team can play out from the back with confidence, it makes pressing them a risky proposition – you commit numbers forward to win the ball, and suddenly you’re exposed if they can play through you.
“They bring a lot of players in the middle, the connection is really good, they break the lines and when that happens they are so, so quick,” Guardiola continued. This is the modern football puzzle in microcosm: compact when defending, explosive when attacking, with the technical quality to transition between the two phases seamlessly. Villa don’t just absorb pressure and counter – they actively look to win the ball in dangerous areas and then exploit the space left behind by overcommitted opponents.
“A really complete team,” Guardiola concluded, and you get the sense he’s not exaggerating for effect. Villa Park has become a genuine fortress, and Emery has assembled a squad that knows how to leverage home advantage to maximum effect.
The Broader Implications
What makes Sunday’s match so fascinating is the confluence of factors at play. City are navigating injury issues in a crucial area of the pitch, facing an opponent that has consistently caused them problems, in a venue where they’ve struggled recently, at a point in the season where the title race narrative is beginning to take shape.
For Villa, this represents an opportunity to make a statement. They’re no longer plucky underdogs hoping to nick a result against the big boys – they’re a legitimate force in the Premier League, a team with European ambitions and the quality to match. A win against City would further cement their credentials and send a message to the rest of the league that they’re not just making up the numbers this season.
For City, it’s a chance to prove that they can win ugly, can adapt without key players, can overcome the kind of tactical challenges that Emery will undoubtedly throw at them. The mark of champions isn’t just winning when everything goes right – it’s finding ways to win when circumstances are less than ideal.
The Beautiful Absurdity of It All
And this, really, is what makes football so endlessly fascinating. Here we have arguably the best manager of his generation, leading the most expensive and theoretically complete squad in world football, openly admitting that he finds one particular away game daunting. We have a title race that’s being declared over and then revived every other week. We have injuries that can derail even the best-laid plans, and tactical puzzles that even the greatest minds struggle to solve.
The absurdity and oddity of the beautiful game, indeed. One moment you’re unstoppable, the next you’re scrambling to find solutions to problems you didn’t know you had. One moment you’re written off, the next you’re favorites. The only constant is change, the only certainty is uncertainty.
As Sunday approaches, both managers will be fine-tuning their tactics, assessing their available personnel, trying to anticipate what the other will do. Guardiola will be hoping that Gonzalez recovers in time, or that Kovacic can fill the void, or that his team can simply outplay Villa despite missing their midfield anchor. Emery will be working on ways to exploit City’s vulnerability, to turn Villa Park’s hostile atmosphere into a twelfth man, to add another chapter to his growing collection of famous victories over supposedly superior opponents.
The beauty of it all is that we won’t know how it unfolds until the referee blows the final whistle. That’s the absurdity, that’s the oddity, and that’s why we keep coming back for more, week after week, season after season. Because in football, as in life, the only thing you can predict with certainty is that your predictions will probably be wrong.
Roll on Sunday. Villa Park awaits, and with it, another installment in the never-ending drama that is the Premier League season.
