WikiSport

View: 4/10 way off it, 8/10 proves point to McInnes – Rangers player ratings vs St Mirren

Rangers did what title challengers are supposed to do in Paisley. They won 2-0, extended their unbeaten run to 12 games and went into the international break one point behind Celtic. It was not a vintage performance, and the match was overshadowed by a contentious penalty, but there was plenty to unpick on the individual front. One player in particular made a strong case that he should not have been left out, while one forward endured a night to forget.

A note on the ratings. I could not see the match myself, so these ratings are built from published reports, mainly Ibrox News and Rangers News, plus match reports and live blogs. Where the outlets disagree, I have said so and settled on a figure that reflects the bulk of the coverage. The commentary is my own reading of what was reported.

The context is straightforward. Derek McInnes made one change for the match, bringing in Dan Neil for Tuur Rommens as the visitors chased three points before the international break. That single switch turned out to be significant. It restored a player whose absence had been felt, and it altered the balance of the midfield in a way that supporters could see within minutes.

Ivor Pandur, goalkeeper, 8. Rangers News singled out the Croatian as the standout performer, which is a rare accolade for a goalkeeper on a night when his team scored twice and controlled much of the play. The headline on that outlet’s ratings said Pandur stars. I do not have a breakdown of individual saves, so I will not invent one, but an 8 for a clean sheet against a side that fought for spells of pressure is a fair reflection. Goalkeepers who keep clean sheets away from home tend to be underrated, and Pandur is increasingly proving his worth.

Dujon Sterling, right-back, 6. The consensus was a steady performance. Sterling is a player whose value often lies in what does not happen: he rarely gets dragged out of position, rarely gives the ball away cheaply and rarely makes a costly mistake. That reliability is not glamorous, but it matters over a long season. He was solid without being spectacular, and a 6 captures that accurately.

Olwethu Makhanya, centre-back, 5. This was one of the weaker marks. Makhanya and Nico Raskin were both given 5 out of 10 in the published ratings. Without a detailed breakdown, it is hard to say precisely why, but a 5 for a centre-back in a clean-sheet win suggests small lapses in concentration or positioning rather than anything catastrophic. St Mirren had spells where they pushed Rangers back, and a defender who is occasionally stretched will mark down in a match like this. He was part of a unit that held firm, which counts for something.

Emmanuel Fernandez, centre-back, 7. Fernandez earned a higher mark from every outlet. He was among those given 7 out of 10 alongside Penrice and Bouanani. That seems about right. The big defender was dominant in the air and commanding in the challenge, and a clean sheet owed plenty to his presence. He has been one of the more consistent players in the back line, and this performance reinforced that.

James Penrice, left-back, 7. The man at the centre of the penalty controversy had a solid evening. He was fouled for the spot-kick, which allowed Naderi to score, and he was a regular presence going forward. He was taken off for Tuur Rommens in the 75th minute. Whatever you think of the decision, Penrice did what wing-backs and full-backs are meant to do, which is to get into advanced positions and force defenders to react. A 7 is a fair mark, and I would not quarrel with anyone who went a point higher.

Nico Raskin, midfield, 5. This was an off night for the Belgian, who has been such a significant figure in recent weeks and whose future has dominated transfer discussion. A 5 is below his usual standard, and it will not worry anyone at Ibrox, because even the best players have quiet nights. There is a certain irony in a player linked with big moves producing a modest performance in a match like this, but it is worth remembering that the team won, and that his overall contribution this season has been strong.

Dan Neil, midfield, 8. The reason this article exists. The summer signing’s goal gave Rangers breathing space, and he also registered a key pass, with his 45 passes the second-most of any Rangers player. That is a strong all-round display, and it matters because of the context. Neil had been left out, and McInnes’s decision to restore him came with obvious consequences. The goal was a fortunate one, as his powerful shot took a lucky deflection that wrong-footed the goalkeeper. But footballers make their own luck, and getting a shot off from distance is what creates those opportunities.

The wider point is about what Neil represents. He is a midfielder who is comfortable on the ball, who links defence and attack and who offers a calm presence in the middle of the pitch. In a team that sometimes becomes fragmented under pressure, that composure is valuable. The verdict in the match report was that McInnes will not be leaving him out of the side against Motherwell in two weeks’ time. That is a clear sign that the performance has changed the manager’s thinking. A player who has been on the fringe forces his way back into the plan by performing when called upon, which is exactly what Neil did.

Badredine Bouanani, wide, 7. The young forward continued to show why supporters are excited about him. He earned a 7 across the board, and his ability to take on defenders and create space gave Rangers something different in attack. Wingers who can beat their man are valuable in tight games, and Bouanani did that more often than not. He is still developing, but the signs are positive, and he offered the kind of direct threat that opposing full-backs found hard to handle.

Minsu Kim, wide, 4. This is where the night became uncomfortable for one of the club’s most expensive signings. Rangers News gave Kim a 4, putting him alongside Kevin Kelsy as a duo who let McInnes down despite the win. The reasons have been discussed in earlier coverage: the South Korean has not produced enough in the final third in recent matches, and this performance did little to change that view. A fee of £8.5 million creates expectations, and while Kim has shown quality at times, the end product has been missing too often. He will have a chance to reset during the international break, and there is every reason to believe he can bounce back.

Ryan Naderi, striker, 6 or 7. The outlets differed here. One gave him a 7 and another a 6, so I will settle on a mark that splits the difference but leans to the generous side, because he scored. Naderi wasted a glorious chance prior to scoring and really should have had more than his one goal. That is the case against him. The case for him is longer. His penalty took him to 14 goal involvements in 18 games, and McInnes praised his growing number nine presence. A striker who gets into good positions is doing the most important part of his job, and the finishing will come. I would say 7, and I would not be surprised if he scored twice next time.

Kevin Kelsy, striker, 4. The headline player for the wrong reasons. Kelsy had four shots but found the target only once, and he was a peripheral figure in a game Rangers were always going to dominate in an attacking sense. That is a harsh but fair summary. A forward who has four attempts and hits the target once has failed to take advantage of the opportunities he was given, and a peripheral figure in a team that controls the match has not made the most of the service. He can be forgiven an off-day. He had scored five times in his last seven appearances before Saturday. One poor night does not undo that good run. But a 4 is deserved, and it is an unusual mark for a player who has been in such form.

The substitutes made smaller impacts. Tuur Rommens replaced Penrice and played out the final stretch. Neil was replaced by Vanja Dragojevic in the 83rd minute. That substitution was an interesting one, because Dragojevic has been a fringe figure in recent weeks, and giving him minutes at the end of a comfortable game was a sensible bit of squad management. Findlay Curtis also appeared, and his late involvement offered a flicker of what might have been. He was picked out by a brilliant Naderi pass, but his touch was poor and allowed the goalkeeper to race out and clear the danger. That miss will rankle, and it is a reminder that talent alone is not enough. Opportunities arrive rarely, and the best players take them.

There is a link here to the discussion about whether Curtis should have been starting instead of Kim. The rating of 4 for Kim and the wasted chance from Curtis show how thin the margins are. Supporters who argued that the youngster deserved a chance would point to Kim’s poor night. Those who argued for patience would point to Curtis’s missed opportunity. Neither case is conclusive, but the match added fuel to the debate, and McInnes will have to decide how to proceed once the break is over.

What does this mean for the team’s overall performance? It would be unfair to describe Rangers as dominant, because much of the first half was a struggle. Rangers toiled for much of the first half before getting the breakthrough via a Ryan Naderi penalty. That is an honest description. The team did not play fluently until the lead arrived, and it took a contentious decision to open the match up. Once ahead, the structure improved, and the second goal killed the contest.

That pattern is worth noting because it speaks to the team’s character. Winning games without playing well is the mark of a good side, and Rangers have been doing that regularly. They have won 10 of their last 12 matches, and the summary on the live blog described them as having the winning habit. Streaks like that do not happen by accident. They reflect fitness, tactical discipline and a manager who knows how to get results even when the performance is not perfect.

The role of the manager deserves a mention. McInnes made a single change and it paid off. Restoring Neil gave the team a platform in midfield, and the decision to stick with the rest of the side showed confidence in a group that had already been performing. Good managers resist the urge to tinker unnecessarily, and this was a masterclass in minimal intervention. The reward was a victory and a boost to the title challenge

St Mirren, for their part, had their moments. The home side produced bursts of pressure and attempts during various spells of the match. They were not outclassed, and their manager had reason to feel aggrieved about the penalty. Craig McLeish lamented another penalty conceded after the match. That frustration is understandable, particularly given the history between the two clubs this season. But it does not change the fact that Rangers were the better side over the ninety minutes, and the scoreline reflected that.

Looking at the ratings as a whole, the picture is of a team with strong foundations and some areas for improvement. The goalkeeper and defence were solid, the midfield was anchored by an excellent performance from Neil, and the attack was efficient if not spectacular. The weak points were Kim and Kelsy, whose lack of impact meant that the team relied on the penalty and a deflected shot for its goals. That is not a sustainable recipe, and the manager will want to see more from the forward line.

The international break comes at a good time. It gives players a chance to rest, to reset and to reflect on their performances. Kim and Kelsy will want to put the poor night behind them, and the manager will use the time to think about how to get the best from them. For others, such as Neil and Naderi, the break is a chance to recover and prepare for the next phase of the season. The momentum is with Rangers, and maintaining it will be the priority.

Overall, a decent night’s work. A clean sheet away from home, a deserved victory and a point separating the team from Celtic at the top of the table. The ratings reflect a team that did enough without excelling, and that is often what separates the contenders from the pretenders. The best sides win ugly when they have to, and Rangers did exactly that

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button