What Sebastien Pocognoli said to Billy Gilmour after Scotland miss left him ‘alone on the pitch’

Every footballer carries the memory of one moment that refuses to fade. For strikers it is usually a miss, and for Scotland supporters of a certain age the miss has a name: Chris Iwelumo, a few yards out against Norway in 2008. Last night at Hampden, for about a minute, it looked as though a new name might be added to that grim list. Billy Gilmour, a midfielder who plays his club football for Napoli, was presented with an open goal at the start of the second half against North Macedonia and somehow put the ball over the bar. What happened next, and what his manager said to him, tells us a good deal about both men.
The miss came less than a minute into the second half, when Gilmour blazed over from eight yards out with the goal gaping after a cut-back from Che Adams. The sound that greeted it was not the roar of a stadium watching a goal. It was the long, collective intake of breath that a crowd makes when it cannot quite believe what it has seen. In a match where Scotland were struggling to break down stubborn opposition, it seemed to sum up the lack of a clinical edge in the final third, and it created an instant sense of dread inside the national stadium.
The timing made it worse. Gilmour had barely had time to settle after the interval, so the miss arrived with the crowd still restless and the game still goalless in the minds of many watching. There is a particular cruelty in missing a chance like that at the start of a half, because there is no time for the moment to blur into the flow of the match. Everyone has just sat down, everyone is watching, and everyone sees it.
Scotland’s head coach, Sebastien Pocognoli, was reportedly straight on to his player. He described the moment after the miss as one in which there was a lot of noise and Gilmour was, in his words, “alone on the pitch.” That phrase is worth dwelling on. A football pitch is a crowded place, with twenty-two players, officials and tens of thousands of people watching. Yet a player who has just made a very public mistake can feel more isolated than at any other time in his career. The manager understood that, and he acted on it.
According to what Pocognoli said afterwards, his message was brief. He called out to encourage Gilmour to carry on, and then told him afterwards that it had been a good reaction. Those are not elaborate words. There was no lengthy speech, no tactical lecture, and no attempt to explain the miss away. It was simply a signal from the dugout that the manager had seen what happened, was not going to punish it, and wanted his player to keep going.
That simplicity is probably the point. When a player has just missed an open goal, the last thing he needs is analysis. What he needs is evidence that the people around him still trust him. A shout of encouragement from the touchline tells him that, and it does so in a way that a post-match conversation never could, because it arrives while the player is still deciding how to respond. Pocognoli also said it is part of football to miss big chances, which is a plain statement of fact that also happens to be exactly what a player in that position needs to hear.
The response from Gilmour was what made the story. He did not hide, and he contributed to Scotland’s win, and he was rewarded with a tremendous ovation from the home crowd, who recognised how brave it was to keep playing through the difficult moments directly after the miss. There is a long tradition in sport of crowds turning on a player who has made a visible error, and an equally important tradition of crowds who choose to back him instead. Hampden chose the second. The ovation suggested that supporters understood what they had just watched: a young man making a mistake and refusing to let it define his evening.
Not every player manages that. Some who miss a chance like that begin to shrink. They stop asking for the ball, they pass sideways, and they try to become invisible. It is a natural human reaction, and managers often substitute a player in that state, either to protect him or to protect the team. Gilmour did the opposite. He kept demanding the ball, kept moving into space, and kept doing the things that make him valuable. In a team that had looked short of ideas, that mattered a great deal.
The comparison with Iwelumo is understandable, and it is also revealing. Both misses came in high-stakes fixtures against opponents who were sitting deep and frustrating Scotland. Both were from very close range at moments when the whole stadium expected a goal. And in both cases, the manager stood to be affected by the consequences. Iwelumo’s miss piled immense pressure on George Burley and resulted in a costly goalless draw that effectively ruined Scotland’s qualification campaign. Gilmour’s miss threatened to derail Pocognoli’s bid for a desperately needed first home win.
The difference lay in what happened afterwards. Where Iwelumo’s error led to a draw and haunted him for years, Gilmour was spared lasting infamy because John McGinn turned his horror moment into a lucky escape. Scotland went on to win 2-1, and what might have been remembered as a disaster became a footnote. That is the cruel arithmetic of football. The size of the miss was the same, but the consequences were completely different, and the difference had nothing to do with the player who missed.
It is also worth saying that the win itself was far from convincing. Scotland limped to victory in uninspiring fashion, as one match report put it, and Pocognoli was celebrating his first victory at Hampden. For a manager who has had an indifferent start, a home win matters whatever the manner of it. He arrived with a reputation as an intelligent young coach and a plan to give Scotland a new identity, and results are what turn a plan into a project. A first home win, even a scrappy one, gives him something to build on.
It has been a short road for the new coach so far. His first match in charge was a goalless draw away to Slovenia in the Nations League, an indifferent start by most accounts, though Gilmour was one of the few players to emerge with credit. Pocognoli has spoken of Gilmour as the smiling assassin of his rebrand, a key man for Scotland for years to come. That is a big thing to say about a player, and it explains why the manager reacted as he did last night. He had invested in Gilmour as a central figure, and a single miss was never going to change that.
Pocognoli has been consistent in his praise. After the Slovenia match, he described Gilmour as a fantastic player and said he really liked him. He called him the type of player modern football is missing, a creative midfielder who always looks forward, is always ready to find solutions, has a clear game plan, offers a good presence around the box, and is very good defensively. He also explained that his half-time change in that match involved moving Gilmour lower on the pitch and dropping the striker Oli McBurnie into a slightly deeper area, with both players becoming more heavily involved in the second half. That detail shows the manager thinks carefully about how to get the best from his midfielder, and it suggests the faith he showed last night is rooted in something more substantial than sentiment.
There is a second layer to the story, which is that Gilmour has had a frustrating run with Scotland. He missed the World Cup after picking up an injury in the warm-up win over Curacao, which meant that the Slovenia match was his first for the national team since that setback. For a player who had waited a long time to get back on the pitch in a Scotland shirt, a miss of that kind on his return to Hampden would have been especially painful. That makes the way he handled it all the more impressive.
His record in a Scotland shirt makes the miss sting a little more. He has scored twice in 51 international appearances, and he should by rights be sitting on three goals for his country. Midfielders of his type are not judged mainly on goals, and he is unlikely ever to feature near the top of the all-time scorers’ list. But every player wants to score for his country, and a chance like that, from eight yards with the goal empty, is the sort that would have lifted a weight.
What can we take from the episode? The first thing is that elite sport is as much about response as about performance. Every player makes mistakes, and the ones who last are those who can absorb them and carry on. Gilmour showed that quality last night in front of a stadium that had just watched him fail at the simplest of tasks. The second is that leadership is often small. A manager who calls out a few words of encouragement at the right moment can change how a player feels about the next ten minutes, and sometimes the next ten years. Pocognoli seemed to understand that instinctively.
The third lesson is about the crowd. Scottish football supporters have a reputation for being demanding, and sometimes unforgiving, but they were generous on this occasion. The ovation was not just a kindness to Gilmour. It was a statement about what kind of atmosphere the fans want at Hampden, one in which players are encouraged to take risks and keep trying. That kind of atmosphere helps a team, and especially a young coaching regime that is still finding its feet.
There is, finally, a point about perspective. A missed chance is a small thing in the grand scheme of a football career. It looks enormous in the moment and then, usually, it shrinks. Iwelumo has spent years being asked about his, and he has handled it with remarkable grace. Gilmour will probably be asked about his for a while too, though with the win secured and the ovation fresh, it is likely to be remembered as a story of recovery and not one of disaster.
For Pocognoli, the evening offered a first home win and a small piece of evidence about how he manages people. He did not shout at a player who had just made an error. He did not substitute him in a panic. He told him to carry on, and afterwards he told him he had reacted well. Those instincts will serve him well over a long qualifying campaign, in which there will be many more difficult moments than this one.
For Gilmour, the lesson is the one that every footballer eventually learns. The miss will not go away, but neither will the way he responded to it. He stayed on the ball, stayed in the game, and earned the respect of the crowd that had gasped at his mistake only minutes earlier. If that is the worst thing that happens to him in a Scotland shirt, he will be doing very well indeed.
A note on sources: this piece draws on match reports and a Scotsman interview write-up covering Pocognoli’s comments after the North Macedonia game. The quotes attributed to Pocognoli come from that reporting and I have kept them short. I could not watch the match myself, so my account of the miss and the reaction relies on those reports. The match report does not say who scored Scotland’s goals beyond crediting McGinn with rescuing the situation, so I have not named scorers.






