Uncategorized

‘Huge Risk’ – SFA official re-analyses Rangers controversy that caused outrage

When a head of refereeing goes on television to explain a decision, the decision has usually become a problem. Willie Collum, the SFA’s head of refereeing, has gone back over the penalty Rangers were awarded for a challenge on James Penrice at St Mirren. The footage has divided former officials, pundits and supporters. Collum’s verdict is that the officiating team got it right. This piece sets out what happened, what Collum said, why the argument is bigger than one penalty, and what it means for Rangers and for Scottish refereeing.

Rangers won 2-0 at St Mirren in Paisley in their last match before the international break. The penalty, awarded by referee Nick Walsh, was the flashpoint. The decision split opinion among former referees and pundits, and ex-referee Steve Conroy accused Penrice of “practicing” his fall to the ground and disagreed with Walsh. That accusation of simulation is what turned a marginal call into an outrage.

Penrice is on loan at Ibrox this season, so he is a recent arrival who has quickly become involved in the argument. The incident came in a game Rangers won, which complicates the story. A penalty that decides a match is bound to be scrutinised, and one that only adds to a lead can still become a talking point once the narrative is set. The debate rests on a few questions:

– Was there enough contact to justify a penalty?

– Did the St Mirren defender touch the ball?

– Did Penrice exaggerate or invite contact?

– Should VAR have stepped in?

Collum addressed all of them On the SFA’s VAR Review programme on Sky Sports, hosted by Gordon Duncan, Collum explained why he thinks the officiating team made the right call, including the point that the St Mirren player takes a huge risk by going in and making contact without touching the ball.

His reasoning has two parts, and they are worth separating.The first part is about the challenge itself.  He accepted that the amount of contact was not great, but said there was contact, and that the St Mirren player did not get close to the ball. This is a careful position. He did not claim it was a heavy foul or that Penrice was wiped out. He argued that minimal contact on a player who has won the right to the ball is still a foul, because the defender committed himself to a challenge he could not win.

The second part is about process. Collum said that once the referee gives the penalty on the field, there is no clear and obvious error for VAR to overturn, and he admitted VAR would not have intervened if Walsh had chosen to play on. That is the more interesting admission, and it explains why the controversy has legs.

Collum’s comment about the opposite scenario deserves more attention than the penalty itself.

VAR in Scotland, as elsewhere, works on a “clear and obvious” threshold. The video official does not re-referee the match. They intervene only when the on-field decision is plainly wrong. That sounds simple, but it produces an uncomfortable result: the same contact can produce different outcomes depending on what the referee decides in real time.

If Walsh gives the penalty, VAR sees enough to support it. If Walsh waves play on, VAR sees insufficient reason to overturn that either. The decision is the same and the contact is the same, but the result depends on the first call.

The explanation has prompted further questions over the VAR “clear and obvious” threshold, with Collum also conceding that the incident had set a bar for similar future incidents. He called it a fair point when it was put to him. That is an honest answer, and it is also a problem for consistency, because supporters of every club will now point to this penalty whenever a similar challenge goes against their team.

Controversies like this are rarely about the single decision. They are about what the decision seems to say. The simulation accusation.  Calling a player a cheat is more inflammatory than disagreeing about whether a challenge was a foul. When a respected former referee accuses a player of rehearsing a fall, the debate turns personal, and Penrice becomes a figure in the story whether he wants to be or not.

The Rangers factor. Any decision involving Rangers or Celtic is amplified in Scottish football. Both clubs have large followings, active media and long histories of complaint about officials. A marginal penalty for one of them is read through that lens.

The wider context. Collum was not only discussing one incident. On the same programme he defended the decision not to send off Celtic’s Colby Donovan against Dundee United. Reports confirm he backed both Walsh’s penalty award to Rangers and the choice not to dismiss Donovan. Defending decisions involving both halves of the Old Firm in one sitting invites accusations of closing ranks, whatever the merits of each call. It helps to separate what the laws of the game require from what officials choose to do.

The laws are fairly clear in principle. A direct free kick, or a penalty inside the area, is awarded when a defender trips, or attempts to trip, an opponent, or challenges carelessly, recklessly or with excessive force. A challenge that misses the ball and makes contact with the player is generally a foul. The attempt to play the ball does not excuse it

The difficulty lies in degree. Football is a contact sport, and not every touch is a foul. Officials are expected to judge whether the contact was sufficient to affect the attacker. That is where the room for disagreement sits, and it is why Collum’s admission that there was not a great deal of contact matters. He is describing a judgement call and supporting it, not claiming certainty

There is also the question of what happens when an attacker goes down. Referees are told to look for exaggeration, and a player who dives is guilty of unsporting behaviour. But a player who feels contact and goes to ground is not necessarily cheating, and a player who is genuinely fouled is not obliged to stay on his feet. The line between those two is the hardest one for an official to draw.

The argument in favour of Walsh and Collum runs as follows. There was contact. Even a small amount is enough if it is the result of a reckless or mistimed challengeThe defender did not get the ball. That removes the usual defence that the player won the ball cleanly. The referee was well placed and made a decision. Walsh saw it live, judged it a foul and pointed to the spot.VAR cannot overturn a reasonable judgement. Under the threshold, a decision that is debatable but defensible should stand.

On this reading, the controversy is mostly about the fall and not about the foul. If a defender commits to a challenge, misses the ball and clips the attacker, he cannot complain much when the referee gives a penalty.

Critics see it differently. The contact was minimal. Collum himself said there was not a great deal of it.The reaction looked disproportionate. Conroy’s view is that Penrice went down more readily than the contact warranted. Penalties are decisive. A spot kick is one of the highest-value events in football, and giving one on thin contact feels harsh. The VAR threshold protects marginal calls in both directions. If a referee had ignored the same incident, it would never have been reviewed, so the outcome rests on one man’s first instinct.

This last point is the strongest criticism, and Collum effectively conceded it. A system that guards against clear errors but not against arbitrary variation produces inconsistent results, and inconsistency is what supporters resent most

For Rangers, the penalty itself matters less than the atmosphere around it. The club is under a new manager, Derek McInnes, who joined in June after Danny Röhl left for Red Bull Salzburg. A new manager wants stability and momentum, and refereeing rows are a distraction from both.

The team’s league form gives some context. Rangers hold the longest unbeaten run in the Premiership this season at ten games, as of 8 November. A side on a run like that does not need a penalty to be competitive, but opponents and rivals will still use a debated decision to suggest that Rangers are getting help. That is how these narratives work: a winning team gets scrutiny, and each marginal decision becomes evidence in an argument.

For McInnes, the sensible response is to say as little as possible. Defending the penalty publicly would invite more argument, and criticising it would be awkward for a club that benefited. The best outcome is for the story to fade once the international break ends and the next match arrives

The larger issue is trust. Scottish refereeing has faced criticism for years, and VAR has not ended it. Supporters across the league feel their club suffers from inconsistent decisions, and every high-profile controversy reinforces that view.

Putting Collum in front of the cameras to explain decisions is a good step. Transparency helps, because supporters are more likely to accept a decision they disagree with if they understand the reasoning. A weekly programme where the head of refereeing walks through incidents does that

But transparency has limits. If the explanation is that the on-field decision stands because it was made on the field, some viewers will conclude that VAR adds little. And if the same explanation is given when decisions go in opposite directions for different clubs, it can look like a justification that fits any outcome.

The fix is not simple. A lower VAR threshold would produce more interventions, more delays and more arguments about what counts as an error. A higher one would leave marginal calls with the referee on the day. Each approach has costs, and Scottish football has not settled on which it prefers.

The Penrice penalty is the latest in a long run of incidents in which the official explanation and the public reaction diverged. The pattern is familiar: a decision, an argument among former officials, an official review and a statement that the original call was correct or at least defensible.

That pattern matters because it shapes how supporters see the game. Each time an incident is explained away, the gap between how fans see a decision and how the governing body describes it widens. Collum’s willingness to concede that VAR would not have intervened in the opposite case is a small step toward closing that gap, because it admits the system has an inherent arbitrariness.

It would be better still if the governing body used such incidents to refine guidance for officials, especially on contact that is minimal and on how to treat falls. Clear guidance reduces the room for dispute, and officials who know what is expected make more consistent decisions

A few conclusions follow.the penalty was defensible, not obvious. Collum’s own language, that there was contact but not a great deal, describes a marginal call. Reasonable people can disagree, and the debate is legitimate.

The VAR admission is the real story. The fact that the same incident would have stood either way shows how much depends on the referee’s first decision. That is worth debating at the level of the system.

The simulation allegation is a separate matter. Whether Penrice exaggerated is a judgement about intent, and it is harder to prove than whether contact occurred. It should be treated with care.

Rangers are not the main issue. The club benefited from a decision, but the underlying argument is about how Scottish football officiates marginal contact

Collum’s re-analysis settles very little. It confirms that the SFA stands behind Walsh’s penalty, that VAR had no reason to intervene, and that the margin between a penalty and no penalty in this case was thin. Whether supporters accept that depends largely on which shirt they wear.

The more useful part of his explanation is the admission about the threshold. It acknowledges what many fans already suspect, that outcomes in marginal cases depend heavily on the first call. If the governing body wants to rebuild trust, it will need to go beyond explaining individual decisions and address that consistency problem directly.

For Rangers, the sensible course is to move on. The team is unbeaten in ten league games, there is a manager trying to build momentum, and the next fixture will soon replace this one in the headlines. For Scottish refereeing, the argument will continue until the system produces decisions that look consistent from one weekend to the next

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button