Graeme Souness reveals why Frank Lampard was his choice for Rangers job

This is a sibling of the Lampard piece I wrote earlier, built on the same story but from a different angle, so I have concentrated on how Souness’s reasoning has evolved and what the decision meant at the time.
There are two kinds of football regret. One belongs to the person who made the decision, the other to the person who only advised on it. Graeme Souness sits firmly in the second camp. When Rangers sacked Michael Beale in October 2023 and went looking for a replacement, the club brought one of its greatest figures into the process. Souness met the candidates, formed a view, and then watched the board choose someone else. Years later, with Philippe Clement long gone and Frank Lampard now coaching at Coventry City, he has explained again why his own preference was the Englishman. The explanation is more layered than a simple “I liked him”, and it says a good deal about how appointments are really made.
The context matters. Rangers in autumn 2023 were a club in flux. Beale’s tenure had unravelled quickly, the squad needed direction, and the board, led by chairman John Bennett and chief executive James Bisgrove, wanted a manager with the stature to steady things. Souness was asked to help, and according to contemporary reports he was advising the board throughout, alongside the director Graeme Park. A shortlist took shape that included Clement, Lampard, Kevin Muscat and others whose names circulated in the press. By the time interviews were under way, the contest had narrowed to two outstanding candidates, in Souness’s own phrase, and he was in the room for both.
What he has said about those interviews has been broadly consistent across the years, which is part of what makes it credible. He has insisted from the start that the final decision was never his. He has also said that he would not be too critical of Lampard, and that the thing which encouraged him most about the former England midfielder was that he actually wanted the job. That sounds obvious, but it is not as trivial as it seems. Many managerial candidates treat an interview as a courtesy call. Souness came away convinced that Lampard fancied Rangers, that he understood what he was walking into, and that he had something to prove.
The motivation point recurs in everything Souness has said. In one version, he described Lampard as someone who did not need the money and wanted to be a successful manager, and who therefore had every reason to give the job everything. In another, he argued that whatever role Lampard took next was effectively a last chance, which would sharpen anyone’s focus. And in a third, he went further, suggesting that Lampard was hurt and angry after difficult spells at Chelsea and Everton, and that a man in that state can be a dangerous animal in the best sense, determined to show that his previous setbacks were the product of circumstances, not of any limitation in ability.
That last reading is perhaps the most interesting, because it runs against the grain of public opinion at the time. Few Rangers supporters wanted Lampard after his fraught spell at Everton, and the club’s decision-makers were, as one commentator put it, entitled to take that into account. Souness took a different view. He saw Chelsea as an almost impossible job when Lampard took it, and he described Everton in blunt terms as a basket case, pointing out that the club had not improved after Lampard left. In effect, he argued that the CV was misleading, that the two most recent jobs were poisoned chalices, and that the right way to read Lampard’s record was to look at the context.
There was also a more practical side to his reasoning, which has resurfaced in the latest comments. Souness told FourFourTwo that he asked Lampard how friendly he still was with Chelsea and Manchester City, and that Lampard said they were. The thinking was straightforward: Rangers did not have lots of money to spend, so perhaps the club could secure players on loan through those connections. It is a very Souness line of thought, pragmatic, resource-focused and unsentimental. He was not looking for a philosopher or a theorist. He wanted a manager who could improve the squad on a limited budget, and a former Chelsea captain with warm relationships at two of the richest clubs in England looked like exactly that.
He has also said that he thought Lampard understood the intensity of the Rangers job, partly through his wife’s family. Souness believed they were Rangers supporters from Northern Ireland, so Lampard would have seen at close quarters what the club means to its people. He added that Lampard had been knocked about in management a couple of times, which was simply part of the profession, and that he knew finishing second is a failure at Rangers. That is a revealing detail, because it shows Souness weighing temperament as heavily as tactics. The Rangers job is notoriously unforgiving, and he wanted someone who would not be surprised by it.
Another thread in his earlier comments concerned geography. Souness said it was a narrow thing, and that the only advantage Lampard had over Clement was that he might understand the west of Scotland a little better. He argued that Lampard’s background in British football gave him a feel for the culture that a continental coach would need time to acquire. That is a sensible observation, and it reflects a long-standing belief among former players that Scottish football has its own rhythms, its own pressures and its own tribal intensity. A manager who arrives from Belgium or France has to learn them quickly, whereas someone from the English game is at least partly acclimatised.
Yet Souness was never dismissive of Clement. If anything, he was generous. He said the Belgian interviewed brilliantly, had presence and a very good CV, and spoke what he considered sensible football. He noted that footballers are cynical judges and that a manager stands in front of them and is assessed from the first minute, so presence and excellent English count for a great deal. In one account he said Clement was the best at the interview, with an impressive presentation, and recalled that the Belgian admitted he had not done this particular type of job before while still delivering something so polished that Souness suspected he had rehearsed it in front of a mirror. That comment, half admiring and half amused, sums up how close the decision was.
Souness also told reporters that he watched Clement’s press conference and concluded that the Belgian understood the demands of the job. That detail is important, because it shows he had not simply dismissed the other candidate. He recognised the qualities that made the board’s choice reasonable, and he even confessed to one concern: that Clement might not click with the intensity of football in Glasgow and in Scotland as a whole. It was a worry, not a prediction, and it is notable that he voiced it publicly. A man who genuinely believed the board had made a mistake would hardly have been so measured.
The aftermath was not entirely smooth. Souness’s willingness to say publicly that Lampard had been his choice attracted criticism. Dave King, the club’s largest individual shareholder, was reported to have said that Souness’s comment did not help, and that if you hold that view you should keep it in house instead of announcing it to everyone. It was a fair point from a boardroom perspective. A new manager needs backing from the first day, and a very public suggestion that a club legend preferred someone else can look like a gift to critics. Souness, for his part, kept saying that he supported Clement fully, and he later admitted he was thrilled by the impact the Belgian made in a short time.
Clement’s start was, by any measure, a good one. He opened his tenure with a 4-0 win over Hibernian, and in the early months there was a sense of renewed purpose around Ibrox. Souness, who had been mentioned in connection with a consultancy or ambassador role, said the idea was simply not going to happen, and that it had been and gone. That chapter closed quietly, leaving only the memory of the interview process and the small controversy about what had been said afterwards.
Over time the story took on a different colour. Clement lasted 16 months and delivered a League Cup before being dismissed, a record that is respectable but not what the club had hoped for. At various points, particularly during difficult periods in the league, commentators looked back and wondered whether Souness had been right. One such moment came after a defeat by Aberdeen left Rangers nine points adrift in the title race, when the question was raised openly. It was an understandable reaction, though as always it rested on a comparison that can never be tested. Nobody knows how Lampard would have fared.
That is the fundamental problem with hindsight in football. The path not taken always looks smoother than the one that was actually travelled. Lampard might have transformed the club, or he might have struggled in precisely the way his critics feared. His career since has been mixed, with moments of promise and moments of difficulty, and he is now working in the English second tier, which suggests a manager still rebuilding his reputation. That does not prove Souness wrong, but it does not prove him right either. It simply shows how uncertain the business of choosing managers is.
What the story does reveal is the logic that guided one influential voice in the room. Souness prioritised hunger, resilience and cultural understanding. He valued practical advantages, such as the ability to bring in loan players through connections. And he was willing to look past a poor recent record if he believed the circumstances had been unfavourable. These are not unreasonable criteria, and they represent a coherent philosophy of recruitment. The board, by contrast, seemed to place more weight on presence, presentation and a strong European CV, and its choice was equally defensible.
It is tempting to turn the episode into a morality tale, with one side wise and the other mistaken, but the reality is more nuanced. The board was entitled to back the candidate who impressed most in the room, and Clement did impress. Souness was entitled to prefer the candidate he thought had the greater desire. Both were making judgements under uncertainty, and neither could know how events would unfold. If there is a lesson, it is that interviews are an imperfect guide and that the best answer on the day does not always translate into the best results over time.
There is also a lesson about communication. Souness’s openness has always been part of his appeal, but it has sometimes created friction. By admitting publicly that his first choice was not the man appointed, he gave the story legs, and every subsequent difficulty at the club invited a glance back at his comments. That is the price of candour, and it is one he seems willing to pay. He has never retracted his view, and he has never used it to undermine the manager the club chose.
For Rangers supporters today, the debate has a different feel. The club is now under Derek McInnes, who took over in the summer and has the team competing for the title. The old argument about Lampard and Clement belongs to an earlier era, and it has little bearing on the present. Yet it remains a useful reminder of how fine the margins are at the top of Scottish football. A single interview, a single answer, a single impression can shape the course of a club for years.
It is also a reminder of the value of continuity and of clear thinking at board level. The best appointments are those made with a clear sense of what the club needs, based on a realistic assessment of the available candidates. Rangers have had mixed results in that area over the years, and the Lampard story is part of that history. It shows that even a well-run process can produce a decision that later looks questionable, and that the people involved will carry their views with them.
In the end, Souness’s account is valuable because it is honest. He does not claim that Lampard would certainly have succeeded, and he does not pretend that Clement was a poor choice. He simply explains what he saw and what he valued, and leaves the rest to others. That restraint is typical of a man who has been around football long enough to know that nothing is certain. His preference was a judgement call, made in good faith, and it remains one of the more intriguing what-ifs in recent Rangers history.
If anything, the continuing interest in the story speaks to the enduring hold Souness has over the club. Supporters still listen when he talks, and what he says still shapes the narrative. That is partly because of his playing and managerial legacy, and partly because he has never been afraid to say what he thinks. In a game full of careful statements, that directness is rare.
So the answer to why Souness wanted Lampard comes down to a handful of things: appetite, resilience, a sense that recent failures were unfair, a feel for the culture, and a practical hope of loan deals through friendly clubs. None of them guarantees success, but together they made a case that persuaded a very experienced judge. The board listened, thanked him, and went another way. That is how these things work, and it is how the story will be remembered.
A note on sources: this piece draws on reports of Souness’s comments to talkSPORT, FourFourTwo and Viaplay, as carried by the Daily Record, the Scotsman, STV, the National, Football Scotland, GlasgowWorld and Rangers Review. Some quotations come from interviews given in 2023 and 2024 and others from the latest FourFourTwo interview, and I have kept direct quotation to a minimum and paraphrased the rest. I could not verify every detail of how the panel reached its decision, and the account of Lampard’s current role comes from the latest reports. I kept it as flowing prose with no subheadings, as in the other pieces. If you’d like it shorter or more opinionated, tell me and I will adjust.






