WikiSport

Rangers star Olwethu Makhanya’s ‘unbelievable’ exploits at Ibrox earn …

Few summer signings at Ibrox have been greeted with less fanfare and justified themselves faster than Olwethu Makhanya. A 22-year-old centre-back from South Africa, arriving from Major League Soccer for a modest fee, was never going to dominate the headlines when he walked through the door. A few months later, supporters are calling him the signing of the season, former Manchester United players are lining up to praise him, and the conversation has moved from whether he can cope with Scottish football to how much Rangers might one day sell him for.

Your headline is cut off after the word “earn”, so I do not know whether the original piece says what those exploits have earned him. I built this from the other reporting I found, and I have not attributed anything to The Scottish Sun itself. Note that your original may differ.

The latest endorsement comes from a fellow countryman with serious credentials. Former Manchester United star Quinton Fortune reckons Makhanya’s move to Rangers has been a huge success. Fortune knows what it takes to succeed at a big club far from home, having made his own way from South Africa to the Premier League, and his verdict carries weight with South African supporters. The defender has won plenty of plaudits after a fine start to his Ibrox career following his £3 million summer move from Philadelphia Union.

That price tag is a key part of the story. At around £3 million, the transfer looked sensible but unremarkable when it was agreed. Makhanya cost Rangers a fee worth around £3 million, according to Sky Sports, with no mention of included add-ons. Compared with the sums spent on some other signings, it is small, and the contrast with his current reputation is what makes his rise so striking. Few players deliver this kind of return so quickly.

To understand how he arrived at Ibrox, it helps to look at his path. He was born in South Africa in April 2004 and came through the domestic game before heading overseas. He joined Philadelphia Union from Stellenbosch in July 2023 through Major League Soccer’s U22 Initiative, a programme designed to attract young international talent to the league. That scheme gave him a platform to develop in a competitive environment, and he took it. Under compatriot Bradley Carnell, he became a regular in the first team, having started out with the club’s reserve side.

His time in America brought one moment that travelled far beyond the league. A video of Makhanya in a fierce duel with Inter Miami’s Lionel Messi went viral and continued to circulate long after the match. Facing one of the greatest players in history and holding his own is the sort of experience that tests a young defender’s nerve. Former Orlando Pirates forward Jerry Sikhosana used it as evidence that he deserved a place in the national squad, describing how Makhanya had man-marked Messi. That kind of exposure helped put him on the radar of European clubs, and Rangers moved decisively.

 

Not everybody at Ibrox was convinced at first. Some Rangers fans were understandably sceptical when the club looked across the Atlantic for a new centre-half and targeted a 22-year-old South African who was not a household name. That scepticism was reasonable. Supporters have seen too many unproven signings fail to adapt, and an MLS defender with limited exposure to the Scottish game was a risk. The early evidence suggests that the risk has paid off.

The turning point came in the big matches. Derek McInnes preferred Makhanya and Emmanuel Fernandez at the back, and the pair were up to the task in the Old Firm derby at Ibrox. The Rangers News ratings for that win were glowing. Makhanya stood out for his quality on the ball, dribbling around Celtic players, and was given a rating of 9 out of 10. Against a side that was supposed to test his experience and nerve, he looked entirely at home.

He followed it up in the return fixture at Celtic Park. By then, he was already attracting attention for the apparent ease of his performances. Andy Halliday said the biggest compliment he could pay him was that he goes unnoticed in games while doing the basics so well, noting that he had never seen him make a slide tackle because of his positioning. That is a valuable observation. The best defenders are often those who make the game look simple, anticipating danger and cutting it out before it becomes a threat. A spectacular tackle may excite the crowd, but a perfectly timed interception does more for the team.

That same match produced a moment that supporters will remember. Makhanya came close to scoring his first goal for Rangers when the ball bounced off him and he struck a superb volley into the top corner, only for it to be ruled out. Halliday’s reaction to the disallowed effort was telling. He said it would have been the goal of the season if it had stood. For a centre-back, a long-range volley in an Old Firm game is the kind of thing that cements a reputation, and the fact that it did not count is one of the minor injustices of football.

Individual recognition followed quickly. Makhanya’s form earned him the Rangers player of the month award for September, wider recognition of his performances at Ibrox. Awards like that matter because they reflect the views of supporters, who are often the toughest judges of a new signing. Winning one within weeks of arriving shows how swiftly he has won them over.

There was also a gesture of support from a legend of the club. Makhanya revealed that a former Rangers captain, regarded as a dominant centre-half himself, had been in touch to congratulate him on the start to his Ibrox career. Being noticed by someone who defined the position at the club is a significant honour for a young player. Former captains rarely send messages of congratulation lightly, and the support shows how highly the defender is regarded by the club’s past as well as its present

Another feature of his game is the versatility he has displayed. Makhanya is naturally a right-sided defender who curiously plays on the left-hand side of Rangers’ back line. That adds to the impression of a player who adapts quickly and handles whatever he is asked to do. Playing on the opposite side to your natural foot is tricky, as it affects your angles of passing and the way you turn, but he has handled it with composure. That composure has become one of his trademarks.

All of this has naturally led to speculation about his future. The most striking claim is the scale of the potential sale. Ibrox News reported that Rangers were being backed to make a £27 million profit on Makhanya as English clubs circled, with the defender tipped to become the first £30 million sale from Scottish football. The existing record, according to the same report, is £26 million, paid by Brighton for a former Celtic midfielder. If Makhanya moved for more than that, it would change the picture of what Scottish clubs can earn from their best young players.

Those figures are projections rather than offers, and they should be treated with caution. The market for defenders, particularly young ones with room to improve, is unpredictable. Clubs in England have the money to pay such fees, but whether they would is another matter, and a transfer of that size would require a bidder who believes the player will keep developing. Still, the fact that the discussion has reached those levels so soon says a lot about the impression he has made

There is another view, which many supporters share: that Rangers should not sell. Ibrox News argued that selling Makhanya in January would be a silly decision to make, no matter how much money is waved in the face of Ibrox chiefs. That is a sentiment that resonates with fans who have watched talented players leave too early before. A defender who is settled, popular and improving is worth more to a club chasing trophies than a cheque, particularly if the money cannot be easily reinvested in a replacement of equivalent quality.

The tension between keeping and selling is familiar to anyone who follows Scottish football. Clubs here operate in a market where they develop players and sell them on, and the revenue is a crucial part of their business model. At the same time, supporters want to see their best players stay and compete for titles. Balancing those pressures is one of the hardest jobs in football management, and Rangers will face the question in the coming months.

For now, the more immediate concern is performance. Not every match has been perfect, and honesty requires acknowledging that. In the 2-0 win over St Mirren on Saturday, Makhanya was among those who received 5 out of 10 in published ratings. That was a quieter night, and it reminds us that even the best young defenders have off days. The important thing is how they respond. A player who bounces back from a below-par performance shows the mental strength that separates the good from the great.

Looking at the bigger picture, the Makhanya story illustrates what a smart recruitment strategy can achieve. Rangers identified a young player with potential, paid a reasonable price and gave him the opportunity to prove himself. The coaching staff have also played their part. Coverage of his progress has pointed to the role of Mark Haskins in helping him develop. A good coaching environment is essential for any young player, and the combination of talent, opportunity and guidance has produced excellent results.

It also demonstrates how important it is to look beyond the traditional recruitment markets. Players from MLS, from South Africa and from other regions that British clubs have not always explored can offer value that is overlooked elsewhere. A defender who has faced forwards of Messi’s calibre in a competitive environment brings experience that cannot be replicated in training. Rangers appear to have understood that, and other clubs will no doubt take note.

There is a sense of optimism around the squad as a result. The defence has been a point of discussion in recent seasons, with questions about its frailty and consistency. The partnership between Makhanya and Fernandez has begun to address those concerns. They complement each other, with one offering aerial dominance and the other composure on the ball, and together they provide a solid base for the team. That stability is a major reason Rangers have strung together such an impressive run of results.

The impact extends beyond the back four. A defender who is comfortable on the ball allows the team to play out from the back, which in turn creates more options in midfield and attack. Makhanya’s ability to dribble past opponents and make progressive passes has become a feature of Rangers’ play, and it helps them break pressure. That kind of defender is increasingly valuable in the modern game, where teams are expected to build from the back and maintain possession.

For South African football, his success is also a source of pride. Players from the country have long made their mark in the game, and each new success story inspires the next generation. Fortune’s comments reflect a sense of kinship, of one South African recognising another’s achievements. If Makhanya continues to progress, he could become a leading figure for his country, and perhaps a role model for aspiring defenders at home.

Of course, challenges lie ahead. Opposition teams will study him, find his weaknesses and try to exploit them. The pressure of playing for Rangers intensifies during a title race, and the margin for error shrinks. Young players can struggle when expectations rise, and the transition from promising newcomer to established star is never straightforward. But everything about his approach so far suggests that he is equipped to handle it.

The next few weeks will be crucial. The international break provides a chance to rest, and the second half of the season will bring bigger tests. If Makhanya can maintain his standards, he will cement his place as one of the best defenders in the league. If he stumbles, the criticism will come quickly, as it does for every Rangers player. Either way, the story so far has been remarkable.

When Fortune called the move a success, he was echoing a view that has spread through the club’s support. It is rare for a signing to be embraced so quickly, and rarer still for one to be valued so highly within months. The combination of a low fee, an impressive start and a big reputation has made Makhanya one of the most talked-about players in Scotland.

In the end, what matters is what happens on the pitch. Supporters will judge him by his performances in the games that count, and so far he has delivered. Whether he stays at Ibrox for years or moves on for a record fee, his early exploits have already earned him a place in the affections of Rangers fans, and the word unbelievable, in this case, does not seem like exaggerati

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button