Derek McInnes pinpoints Rangers biggest strength as St Mirren fume over penalty award and VAR consistency

Good teams win in different ways. Some dominate possession, some overwhelm opponents with attacking flair, and some simply refuse to concede. On Saturday night in Paisley, Rangers did a little of each, but it was the last of those qualities that Derek McInnes dwelt on afterwards. His side beat St Mirren 2-0 to extend their unbeaten domestic run to 12 matches, and the manager used the occasion to highlight what he sees as the foundation of the team’s progress. St Mirren’s head coach, meanwhile, used his own post-match appearance to question a first-half penalty and the consistency of the officials.
A note on sourcing: I built this from several published match reports and manager interviews. I have paraphrased McInnes’s and Craig McLeish’s comments rather than quoting them at length, and where a report describes something as McInnes’s “biggest strength”, I have followed the reporting and said so. I could not read every word of the original article, so the framing is partly my own inference from the coverage.
The result itself was a significant one. Rangers left Paisley with another clean sheet, extending their unbeaten domestic run to 12 matches with a comfortable 2-0 victory. It also ended a frustrating spell on the road. Rangers had dropped points on successive away trips and had not won on the road in the league since the victory at Parkhead in September, just before the previous international break. For a team with title ambitions, that kind of away form was a concern, and the win answered it at exactly the right moment.
McInnes was in a positive mood, though not an uncritical one. He said Rangers were showing encouraging signs of progress, but acknowledged St Mirren’s willingness to press, commit players forward and test the visitors’ defensive organisation. That balance is typical of the manager. He is rarely effusive in victory and rarely overly negative in defeat, preferring to assess matches in measured terms. What stood out this time was where he placed the emphasis.
The headline answer, according to the reporting, is the defensive resilience that has underpinned Rangers’ recent revival. Rangers continue to demonstrate the defensive resilience that has underpinned their domestic revival. That is a significant statement for a club whose back line was a source of anxiety in recent seasons. A team that keeps clean sheets regularly gives itself a margin for error in attack, and over a long season that margin often decides titles.
At the heart of that resilience stands the goalkeeper. McInnes was thrilled with Ivor Pandur, who produced several important saves to preserve the clean sheet as St Mirren threatened a comeback in the closing stages. It is worth dwelling on the timing of those saves. A 2-0 lead can feel comfortable, but a goal for the home side at the end would have changed the mood completely, and Pandur’s interventions kept the contest closed.
The manager went further in his praise. McInnes believes the Croatian’s consistency has become an important foundation for his team. That word, foundation, is revealing. It suggests that the manager sees Pandur not simply as a good performer but as a structural element on which the rest of the side can build. Goalkeepers who are reliable week after week allow defenders to take risks, midfielders to press higher and strikers to attack with confidence.
The defensive unit in front of him has benefited from stability. The partnership at centre-back has been consistent, and the full-backs have been trusted to contribute going forward. The result is a team that does not concede cheap goals, which matters in a league where games against organised opponents are often decided by a single moment. Rangers have shown a capacity to defend a lead, and that is something supporters have wanted to see for years.
That does not mean the attacking play is without merit. McInnes was effusive about Ryan Naderi, who scored the opening goal from the penalty spot. The forward put the disappointment of an early miss quickly behind him to break the deadlock from the penalty spot after 18 minutes. That detail is important. Missing a chance and then converting a penalty requires mental strength, and it speaks to the confidence he is building. The penalty took him to 14 goal involvements in 18 games, and McInnes praised his growing number nine presence.
The manager’s comments about Naderi focused on qualities that go beyond goalscoring. McInnes was effusive in his praise of the striker’s physicality, work rate and ability to stretch opposition defences. Those are the qualities that make a forward valuable in a team that wants to play with width and speed. A striker who stretches the defence creates space for those behind him, and Naderi’s willingness to run channels and hold the ball up has been central to Rangers’ improvement in attack.
McInnes was also frank about what the team could do better. He acknowledged the irony that Rangers scored two goals, from a penalty and a deflected shot at the edge of the box, given all the chances created. That is a candid assessment, and it matches what the data suggested. Rangers posted their highest expected-goals figure away from home this season, even without counting the penalty. In other words, the performance was better than the scoreline might suggest, and the finishing could have been sharper.
That tension between creation and conversion is a recurring theme. The front four generated opportunities but failed to maximise them, and a more clinical team would have won by a bigger margin. It is a problem many managers would happily take, because creating chances is harder to teach than finishing them. Over time, a team that consistently reaches good positions will score more, and the manager appears confident that the finishing will come.
There is also the tactical question. McInnes has been honing a 4-4-2 system since the bold team selection at Parkhead, and he intends to keep developing it on the road rather than adapting his approach away from home. That is a significant commitment. Many managers become more conservative away from home, but McInnes has chosen to persist with his preferred shape, accepting short-term risks in exchange for long-term improvement. Saturday’s win suggests that the approach is beginning to pay off.
The St Mirren perspective was very different, and it is worth hearing in full. Saints have now claimed just one win in their last nine games, and McLeish was frustrated by the first-half penalty, questioning the consistency of the decisions made by officials following Samuel Ramos’ challenge on James Penrice. A run like that puts pressure on any head coach, and a controversial decision at a crucial moment feels like salt in the wound.
McLeish was measured in his analysis, even if his frustration was evident. He accepted that if the referee gives the penalty on the field, it is perhaps difficult for VAR to overturn it. That acknowledgement is fair, and it reflects a good understanding of how the system works. VAR is designed to correct clear and obvious errors, not to second-guess every judgement call. A referee who is well positioned and makes a decision with confidence is unlikely to be overruled unless the evidence is overwhelming.
His frustration stemmed more from the question of consistency. St Mirren have felt aggrieved before. The earlier fixture at Ibrox produced a dispute over a penalty claim that went the other way, and there is a sense at the Paisley club that big decisions have not been falling their way. McLeish lamented another penalty conceded after the match, with the controversial opener setting Rangers on their way. The word another is revealing. It implies a pattern in McLeish’s mind, whether or not the statistics support it.
When asked whether he would seek clarification from the referee, his reply was blunt. Asked whether he had spoken to Nick Walsh after the final whistle, McLeish said there was no point. That response is telling. It suggests a degree of resignation, a belief that conversations with match officials are unlikely to change anything. Managers often take that stance after a defeat, but it is also a symptom of a wider issue in Scottish football: the communication between referees and clubs.
The disagreement over the penalty itself has been well covered. Former referee Keith Hackett backed the spot-kick, saying Ramos’ challenge was careless despite Chris Sutton’s criticism that Penrice had played the referee like a piccolo. That divided opinion is a fair reflection of the incident. Some see minor contact and a player going down easily, while others see a careless challenge that fits the definition of a foul. The laws support the second reading, but the first is understandable, which is why the debate has lingered.
For McInnes, the controversy was largely a sideshow. His focus was on the performance and on the lessons to be drawn from it. A manager who has spent his career in the Scottish game knows that refereeing decisions are part of the landscape, and he has also been on the other side of them. As Kilmarnock manager, he voiced his own frustration about VAR consistency, so he can empathise with McLeish’s position, even if he benefited this time.
The wider context adds weight to the result. Rangers moved within one point of Celtic with the win. In a title race, every point matters, and the difference between a win and a draw can shape the entire season. Celtic’s response in their own match on Sunday would determine whether the gap stayed at one or widened again, but for the time being, Rangers had done everything required.
That pressure also explains why the manager was keen to emphasise the positives. A team that is unbeaten in 12 games, with clean sheets accumulating and key players in form, has reason to be confident. But McInnes is also aware that complacency is the enemy of progress. The areas he highlighted for improvement, particularly the clinical edge in front of goal, are exactly the ones that could decide a close title race.
The balance between defence and attack is what makes the current Rangers team interesting. For years, the club’s identity was built on possession and territorial dominance, which often left it vulnerable on the counter-attack. McInnes has brought a different philosophy, one that values solidity and directness. The results so far suggest that the approach is working, but it also carries risks. A team that relies on a strong defence can struggle when it concedes first, and the manager will want to prove that his side can also come from behind.
The contributions of individual players have been significant. Beyond Pandur and Naderi, the centre-back partnership has been commanding, the midfield has benefited from Dan Neil’s return to the starting line-up, and the wide players have offered a threat. Neil’s deflected strike for the second goal may have been fortunate, but it was the product of a willingness to shoot and the sort of attacking intent that creates luck. A team that plays with conviction tends to get its share of good fortune
Supporters will take encouragement from the manager’s tone. McInnes is not a manager given to hyperbole, and when he describes progress, he generally means it. The pattern of the last few weeks, which has seen the team grind out results even when not at its best, is a sign of maturity. Title-winning sides often lose their way for a stretch and still manage to win, and Rangers are beginning to show that capacity.
The remaining question is whether this form can be sustained. The international break gives players a rest, but it also interrupts momentum. Some teams return from such breaks sharper, while others take time to rediscover their rhythm. McInnes will want to ensure that his squad returns focused and fit, and the depth he has built will be tested by injuries and suspensions.
There is also the matter of expectations. As the gap to Celtic narrows, the scrutiny on Rangers will intensify. Every decision, every result and every performance will be analysed through the lens of the title race. That is a challenge for any club, but it is also an opportunity. The players who thrive under pressure will define the season, and the manager’s calm approach may help them stay grounded.
For St Mirren, the focus must turn to survival and improvement. One win in nine is not a position any manager wants to be in, and McLeish will be aware that results, not grievances, will determine his future. Complaining about penalties will not change the table, and the best response to disappointment is to win the next match. The squad has quality, and there are signs that they can compete when everything clicks, but they need to find consistency.
Looking at the bigger picture, Saturday’s match illustrated the two sides of football’s emotional spectrum. For Rangers, it was a night of progress and quiet satisfaction. For St Mirren, it was another evening of frustration. Both reactions are understandable, and both will fade as the next fixtures approach. What remains is the sense that Rangers are building something, and that its foundation is a defence and goalkeeper capable of holding firm.
In the end, McInnes’s message was simple: the team is heading in the right direction. Whether that proves to be enough to catch Celtic is a question for the coming months, but the evidence of the last 12 matches suggests that the club has found a formula that works. A strong defence, a reliable goalkeeper, a striker in form and a manager with a clear plan are the ingredients of a serious challenger.
St Mirren will keep arguing about the penalty, and the debate over VAR consistency will continue. But for Rangers, the story is one of resilience, and resilience, as McInnes knows, is what wins titles







