WikiSport

Pundit highlights ‘clear and obvious stigma’ with VAR as St Mirren vs Rangers incident sums up threshold issue

VAR was brought into football to eliminate “clear and obvious” errors, yet the phrase has become the most argued-over in the Scottish game. The latest St Mirren vs Rangers flashpoint has pundits saying the system carries a “clear and obvious stigma”, and it shows why the debate never seems to end.

The threshold looks simple on paper. The referee makes a call on the pitch, and VAR only steps in if that call is plainly wrong. In practice, “clear and obvious” means something different to everyone watching. A supporter sees a replay from three angles and thinks the answer is staring them in the face. The official in the booth has to decide whether the on-field referee’s view was so flawed that overruling it is justified. Those two judgements rarely match, and the gap between them is where the anger starts.

Incidents like this one expose the problem because they fall into the grey area. When a decision is borderline, one side will call it a mistake VAR should have fixed, while the other argues the referee was entitled to make the call. Nobody is entirely wrong, but nobody is satisfied either. A system built to settle arguments ends up feeding them.

The stigma comes from the inconsistency. Fans can accept a referee getting a split-second decision wrong, because that has always been part of the game. They find it much harder to accept a team of officials with replays and time who still leave a questionable call standing. That feels less like human error and more like a failure of the process, and it erodes trust.

Scottish football now needs clearer communication and more consistent application of the threshold. Until supporters understand why VAR intervenes in one case and stays silent in another, every contentious moment will become another chapter in the same argument.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button