A Soft Penalty, a Short Review and a Familiar Argument: Rangers, St Mirren and the VAR Question

Football in Scotland has a talent for turning a single moment into a week-long argument. On Saturday 7 November, Rangers travelled to St Mirren and won 2-0. By the time the pundits had finished, the scoreline was a footnote and the main story was a first-half penalty award that left St Mirren feeling wronged and sent the analysts back to their replays.
The facts are simple. About midway through the first half, St Mirren’s Samuel Ramos challenged Rangers left-back James Penrice inside the box. Referee Nick Walsh pointed to the spot almost immediately. Reports said Ramos appeared to make minimal contact. VAR took a short look, but Walsh’s on-field decision stood and the penalty was given. Rangers took the lead from the spot, and the contest never looked quite the same afterwards.
The argument that followed was less about the result than about the moment itself. Had Penrice been fouled? Had he exaggerated the contact? And should the video assistant have asked the referee to look at the pitchside monitor? Each question leads to a larger one about how modern officiating deals with marginal contact. This piece takes them in turn
The reaction came quickly and was largely one-sided. The Daily Record’s coverage was built around Steven Thompson, the former Rangers and St Mirren striker who appeared on BBC Sportscene. Thompson has played for both clubs, which makes his view harder to dismiss as tribal. He put the incident in the “extraordinarily soft” category and said he didn’t think there was enough in it to warrant a penalty.
His comments went beyond the contact itself. He pointed to a familiar dynamic: home supporters will always say a penalty shouldn’t have been given against them, but imagine the roles reversed. If the same incident had gone against Rangers, he suggested, Derek McInnes would have been asked about it and would have had plenty to say. It’s an argument about consistency of reaction, and it asks the viewer to imagine how they’d feel if the shoe were on the other foot.
Andy Halliday, another former Rangers player, focused on the physical side of the incident. In his view Penrice went down right in front of the referee, and that kind of fall can influence an official. Halliday didn’t make Walsh the main target. He said he didn’t necessarily blame the referee and that his real question was why VAR hadn’t brought him over to the monitor for a second look.
Two former SPFL referees, Steve Conroy and Des Roache, reached the same conclusion from a technical standpoint. Both reckoned the decision should have been overturned by VAR. The Ref’s View podcast made the same point on social media, describing it as a very soft penalty without a lot of contact and saying VAR should have overturned it.
Chris Sutton added colour on commentary, saying Penrice had “played Nick Walsh like a piccolo.” It’s a vivid line, and it reflects how the incident looked to a viewer watching in real time: contact so slight that the fall looked like the decisive act.
Taken together, the former players and referees were nearly unanimous, which is unusual in a sport where almost any decision can find a defender. The disagreement was never really about whether the penalty was soft. It was about whether softness alone justified overturning a referee’s call.
The other side deserves a fair hearing, and Rangers will make it. The argument is that contact doesn’t need to be heavy to be a foul. A defender who touches an attacker’s leg or interferes with his stride has still committed an offence if the touch is enough to disrupt his balance or movement. A player running at pace, shifting his weight and changing direction can be unsettled by very little, and the attacker is under no obligation to stay on his feet when impeded.
Rangers will argue that Penrice was impeded. Seen that way, the fall is a reaction to the touch, not a decision to go to ground. On this reading, the fact that the contact was minimal doesn’t make the challenge legal. It just means the contact was efficient, because a small touch at the right moment can be as effective as a large one.
Walsh was also close to the incident, and he was quick to point to the spot. Referees aren’t expected to decide cases like this in slow motion. They read the speed of the player, the position of the defender’s feet and whether the contact altered the attacker’s movement, and they do it in a fraction of a second. A referee who sees that and gives the foul is working within his remit, and that matters for what comes next
The deeper question is why VAR didn’t intervene, and that depends on what the system is for. VAR was introduced to correct clear and obvious errors, and for penalty decisions that means checking whether the referee has missed or misjudged something to a degree that can’t reasonably be defended. It was never meant to re-referee every marginal call.
That principle explains a lot of the frustration around the system. If a challenge could reasonably be given or not given, the protocol says the on-field decision should stand. The video official’s role isn’t to substitute a preferred view but to step in when the call falls outside the range of reasonable outcomes.
Applied to this incident, the debate becomes a precise one. The pundits who criticised the decision believe the contact was so slight, and the reaction so pronounced, that the award fell outside that range. The defenders of the decision, or at least of the non-intervention, would say a small touch on a moving attacker is exactly the kind of thing referees give, so it didn’t meet the “clear and obvious” bar. The two sides are not far apart on the facts. They differ on where to draw the line.
Where that line sits has always been part of the problem. What looks obviously wrong to a former referee watching a slowed replay may look arguable to the official who has just seen it in real time and has to decide whether a review is warranted. Different people draw it in different places, and the same person may draw it differently from week to week. That is a structural difficulty, not a failing peculiar to one official.
It helps to separate three questions that tend to get blurred in these debates.
The first is whether there was contact. Here the reports say there was, though minimal. That matters, because if there is no contact at all, the case for a penalty collapses and the incident becomes one of simulation, where the attacker should be cautioned for trying to deceive the referee.
The second is whether the contact was enough to constitute a foul. The laws speak of a player who tackles or challenges an opponent in a manner that is careless, reckless or uses excessive force. A trip, or an attempt to trip, falls under the direct free kick offences. In principle a light touch to the leg can qualify if it has the effect of impeding the opponent. There is no minimum threshold of force, and the test is about what the contact does, not how hard it was.
The third is whether the attacker has exaggerated the effect. A player who feels contact and goes down more dramatically than the touch warrants hasn’t necessarily committed an offence, but the referee is entitled to weigh the exaggeration when deciding whether the contact really caused the fall. That is the area Halliday and Sutton were pointing at. Their view is that the touch was too slight to explain the fall, which suggests the fall was a response to the situation and not to the contact.
All three questions are matters of judgment, and none has a clean answer. That is why the incident divided opinion even though most of the commentators ended up in the same place.
There’s a procedural question inside the larger debate. VAR can recommend a review, but only the referee can decide what to do after he has watched it. Walsh’s decision stood after what was described as a short look, so the video official examined the incident and decided there wasn’t enough to ask the referee to go to the monitor, or that the referee had already seen enough.
Critics argue that going to the monitor costs nothing and allows the referee to take a calmer view than he could at pitch level. A referee who has just awarded a penalty with minimal contact might well change his mind after seeing the slow-motion replay. Halliday’s point fits this: it isn’t that Walsh must have got it wrong, but that a second look was the obvious response.
The counterargument is that the system works best when interventions are rare. If VAR sends the referee to the monitor every time a decision is contested, matches slow down and the referee’s authority is eroded. The balance between thoroughness and flow is one the game has never settled.
This wasn’t the first time the Daily Record and its pundits had examined a Rangers penalty incident involving St Mirren this season, and the contrast is instructive. In an earlier match, a late win for Rangers, the discussion went the other way. Halliday criticised VAR after St Mirren’s Ismeal Kabia appeared to be upended in the box by Emmanuel Fernandez, with only a smattering of appeals made to referee Don Robertson. His view was that VAR official Steven McLean had made a serious error by not asking the referee to check the pitchside monitor.
Halliday said then that he could forgive a referee for missing the contact live, given how little the St Mirren players had appealed. But, in his words, VAR has to pick those scenarios up. There is no doubt in his mind, he said, that the contact was initiated by Fernandez and not by Kabia.
Set against the Penrice incident, this is revealing. In the earlier match the complaint was that VAR had failed to intervene when a penalty should have been awarded against Rangers. In this one the complaint is that VAR failed to intervene when a penalty should not have been awarded to them. Halliday’s logic is consistent across both: VAR should be catching decisions where the replay tells a different story from the one the referee saw. The criticism is aimed at the process more than at either club, and that is probably the fairest way to read it.
It also illustrates why supporters of both clubs can feel aggrieved at once. A system that intervenes unpredictably will, over a season, leave every club with a grievance. St Mirren’s frustrations in this match sit beside those that have been felt by other clubs in other fixtures.
Thompson’s observation about home supporters being quick to say a penalty against them shouldn’t have been given deserves attention, because it applies to everyone. People judge incidents through the colour of their shirts, and the same challenge can look like a clear foul or a soft tumble depending on the badge on the player’s chest.
That is part of why the opinions of neutral former referees carry weight. Conroy and Roache aren’t invested in the result, and they approached the incident as a question of interpretation under the laws. Their agreement that VAR should have stepped in is more persuasive than a St Mirren supporter’s anger or a Rangers supporter’s defence.
It’s worth noting that the pundits were not all neutral. Thompson and Halliday have both played for Rangers, and Thompson for St Mirren too. But the fact that two former Ibrox players were willing to criticise the decision, even though it favoured their old club, suggests the view wasn’t driven by loyalty. If anything, it cuts against the idea that the criticism came from the home side’s corner.
The penalty came midway through the first half, so it shaped the game from an early stage. A side that goes a goal behind to a contested decision often responds in one of two ways. Some push forward with extra urgency, which can leave gaps. Others become distracted by the sense of injustice and lose concentration. Which of these happened is hard to say from the reports I have, and it would be unfair to claim the penalty decided the result. Rangers won 2-0, and a second goal suggests they did more than ride one decision.
Still, one early decision can change the tactical complexion of an afternoon. A team that was set up to stay compact and wait for chances suddenly has to chase the game. For St Mirren, that meant playing from behind on their own ground against a side that had been handed an early advantage.
The Scotsman’s match report struck a balanced note. It described the penalty controversy as the main talking point while also noting Penrice’s growing influence and Rangers’ wider achievements. That is the right framing. The penalty belongs in the account of the match, but it doesn’t replace the account.
Scottish football’s relationship with VAR has been uneasy since its introduction, and each controversy of this kind feeds the same cycle. A decision is made, the replays circulate, former officials give their verdicts on television and radio, and the discussion turns to the competence or consistency of the officials involved. Months later, another incident arrives and the cycle starts again.
There are three recurring themes. The first is the threshold for intervention, which as discussed is hard to define and harder to apply consistently. The second is communication: supporters rarely hear why a review was or wasn’t undertaken, so the process feels opaque. The third is accountability, because officials who make marginal calls are rarely held to account in a visible way, which leaves fans feeling that nothing changes.
None of these has an easy answer. Greater transparency, with clearer explanations of VAR decisions, would help, as would a more consistent approach to what qualifies as a clear and obvious error. But any system that relies on human judgment will produce disagreement at the margins, and a soft penalty is exactly that kind of marginal case.
So was it a penalty? The honest answer is that it was a decision a referee could make and that most of the former officials and players commenting thought was the wrong one. That puts it in an uncomfortable middle ground. It wasn’t an outrageous decision, but it was a soft one, and softness was the word the analysts kept returning to.
Whether VAR should have intervened is where the real disagreement lies. If the standard is “clear and obvious error”, a strict reading might say that a referee pointing to the spot after minimal contact is within the range of acceptable outcomes. If the standard is “would a second look have changed the outcome”, the answer, according to Conroy, Roache and the others, is probably yes.
For Rangers, the incident is a small asterisk on a comfortable win. For St Mirren, it is another entry in a ledger of decisions that have left them feeling short-changed. And for the wider game, it is another reminder that VAR hasn’t removed controversy so much as moved it, from the moment of the decision to the minutes afterwards, when the replays are replayed and the argument begins.







