The recent Manchester derby between Manchester City and Manchester United, held at Old Trafford on April 6, 2025, concluded in a goalless draw. However, the match was overshadowed by offensive chants directed at City’s midfielder, Phil Foden, by a section of United supporters. These chants, targeting Foden’s mother, prompted strong reactions from various quarters, including City manager Pep Guardiola and Foden himself.
During the first half of the match, certain Manchester United fans were heard chanting derogatory remarks about Phil Foden’s mother, Claire Rowlands. The offensive nature of these chants was evident to those present at the stadium and watching the broadcast. Such behavior not only tarnishes the spirit of the game but also brings into question the boundaries of fan conduct during high-profile matches.
In the post-match press conference, Manchester City manager Pep Guardiola did not mince words when addressing the incident. He labeled the chants as a “lack of class” and emphasized that such behavior reflects poorly on the individuals involved rather than the club as a whole. Guardiola stated, “Honestly, I don’t understand the mind of the people involving the mum of Phil; it’s a lack of integrity, class, and they should be ashamed.”
Guardiola’s condemnation highlights the broader issue of maintaining respect and decorum in football, especially during emotionally charged fixtures like the Manchester derby. He further remarked on the exposure that players and managers have in world football, suggesting that such incidents are not isolated but indicative of a larger
Phil Foden chose to address the incident subtly through social media. On the evening following the match, he posted three photographs from the game on his official Instagram account, accompanied by the caption: “We keep going.” This concise message, while not directly referencing the chants, Foden’s resilience and determination to move forward despite the negativity.
Manchester City expressed shock and disappointment over the chants. Club sources conveyed their disgust at the frequency and volume of the offensive remarks, emphasizing that such behavior has no place in football.
On the other hand, Manchester United reiterated their commitment to combating abusive conduct among supporters. The club emphasized its stance against any form of offensive behavior and is likely to investigate the incident further to ensure appropriate measures are taken.
This incident sheds light on the persistent issue of inappropriate fan behavior in football. While rivalries add excitement to the sport, they should not serve as a pretext for personal attacks or offensive conduct. The targeting of players’ families crosses a line that should be firmly upheld by clubs, governing bodies, and the football community at large.
Furthermore, the incident underscores the responsibility of clubs to educate their supporters about acceptable behavior and the potential consequences of crossing ethical boundaries. It also highlights the need for swift action against individuals who engage in such conduct to maintain the integrity and respect of the sport
The offensive chants directed at Phil Foden during the Manchester derby have rightly drawn condemnation from various quarters. Pep Guardiola’s strong response, coupled with Foden’s composed reaction, exemplifies the professionalism expected at the highest levels of football. As the sport continues to grapple with issues of fan conduct, it becomes imperative for all stakeholders to work collaboratively in fostering an environment of respect, both on and off the pitch.
