A Man United Great Gives His Verdict on Rangers’ South African Defender

When a footballer crosses an ocean to join a new club, the verdict that matters most often comes from someone who has made a similar journey. Olwethu Makhanya’s first months at Rangers have now drawn praise from a fellow South African who knows the pressures of European football very well. Quinton Fortune, formerly of Manchester United and Atletico Madrid, has said the defender’s decision to leave Major League Soccer for the Scottish Premiership was the right one at the right time.
Makhanya joined Rangers this summer from Philadelphia Union for around £3 million. At 24, he has taken to life at Ibrox quickly. Fortune, who watched him in America before the move happened, believes the transfer works for the player and could also do something for South African football as a whole.
Fortune is not someone offering a passing opinion on a countryman for the sake of it. Born in Cape Town, he left South Africa as a young player and built a career in Europe at the top level. He played for Atletico Madrid before joining Manchester United, where he spent several years in the dressing room of one of the most successful sides in English football history. In an era when few South African players reached the heights of the Premier League, he was one of the few who did.
That background shapes how he reads Makhanya’s situation. He knows what it is to arrive in a new country, adapt to a different style of football, deal with scrutiny, and prove yourself in an environment where every error is noticed. When he says a move has been good for a player, he is speaking from experience of what such a transition demands.
It also matters that Fortune watched Makhanya before Rangers came calling. By his own account, he had seen the defender play in MLS, so his praise is not a reaction to a few good results in Scotland. He is placing the Rangers move in the context of a player he had already formed an impression of
Makhanya is a South African centre-back who spent the early part of his professional career in the United States with Philadelphia Union. The Union are a respected club in MLS, known for developing young players and selling them on, and Makhanya fits that pattern. His transfer to Rangers, reported at £3 million, shows the Glasgow club saw something worth investing in.
For a defender at 24, the timing is sensible. He is old enough to have had meaningful first-team experience, but young enough that his best years are still ahead. A move to a club of Rangers’ size, with its fixtures, its crowds, and the weight of its history, is the sort of step that can accelerate a career.
Early signs suggest it is working. Reports around the club have spoken of a fine beginning to his Ibrox career, and he has been earning plaudits from observers. Starting well at a club where the demands are high is not guaranteed, and many signings from other leagues take months to settle. Makhanya appears to have avoided that slow start.
## What Fortune actually said
The most striking word in Fortune’s assessment is the one used in the headline. He described it as unbelievable that Makhanya is now playing for Rangers in the Scottish Premiership. He did not mean it as doubt. He meant it as admiration for how far the defender has come, and he added that moving up a level was exactly what the player needed to do.
Fortune’s reasoning ran along simple lines. He called MLS a good league, but made clear it does not offer what European football does. In his words, European football is just a bigger stage. That stage, he argued, is where Makhanya will keep improving.
This is a widely held view among former players, although it is also debated. MLS has grown considerably in quality and investment, and plenty of its players are good enough for strong European sides. But the argument Fortune is making is less about raw ability and more about environment. Playing week after week in front of intense crowds, in matches where results carry real consequences for a historic club, builds a different kind of player
Fortune singled out one experience in particular: the Old Firm derby. Makhanya has already played in the fixture between Rangers and Celtic, and Fortune said you could not ask for a better football education than that. He described the derby as football at its most pressurised.
For a newcomer, it is hard to overstate how much of an initiation the Old Firm can be. The rivalry is one of the oldest and most intense in world football, and players who join either side are told about it almost from the day they sign. Nothing fully prepares you for the noise, the tension, and the sense that the result will be remembered for weeks.
For a defender, the stakes are even more personal. A mistake in a derby is magnified, and a strong performance can win over supporters quickly. Having faced that test early in his Rangers career, Makhanya has gained something that cannot be taught in training. Players who come through such matches with credit tend to grow in confidence, and that confidence often shows in their performances for the rest of the season.
It is worth noting the context in which Rangers have been playing their recent derbies. Reports from the club’s September run showed Rangers winning six matches in a row, including two victories over Celtic. A new defender arriving into a side with momentum, and getting derby experience in winning matches, has had a much easier introduction than one joining a team in turmoil
Makhanya has not been working alone. One of the stories around Rangers this autumn has been the defensive pairing between him and Emmanuel Fernandez, the Nigeria international centre-back. Fernandez was linked with moves away during the summer, with reports mentioning interest from clubs including Borussia Dortmund and West Ham, but stayed at Ibrox.
Former Rangers defender Kirk Broadfoot praised that decision to keep him, calling Fernandez an excellent all-round athlete who is comfortable on the ball. Commentary around the team has also highlighted how the two centre-backs complement one another. For Makhanya, playing next to an experienced and highly rated partner makes the adjustment easier, because a settled defensive pair can cover for each other while a newcomer learns the league.
Rangers also kept the midfielder Nicolas Raskin, who had been linked with a summer departure. Retaining those players, while adding Makhanya, gave the squad a stable foundation at a time when the club was working to rebuild confidence
Fortune did not limit his comments to Makhanya’s personal prospects. He framed the move as part of a larger process that could help raise the level of South African football. His point was that every time a South African player secures a transfer to a significant European club, it adds to a pathway others can follow.
South African football has a proud history of producing talented individuals, and some have made real impacts abroad. Lucas Radebe became a legend at Leeds United, Benni McCarthy had a successful career in Europe including a Champions League triumph with Porto, and Steven Pienaar was a respected performer in the Premier League. Fortune himself belongs to that group. Yet the number of South Africans competing consistently at the top European level has never been as high as the country’s talent might suggest.
Each new success story changes that. Young players at home see a clear route from the domestic game, through a stepping-stone league like MLS, to a big European club. Scouts and clubs, in turn, take a closer look at what the South African system produces. If Makhanya establishes himself at Rangers, the benefit goes beyond his own career.
Fortune’s wording suggests he sees the move in exactly those terms. It is not only a good deal for one defender and one club. It is another step in a longer effort to get South African players recognised on a bigger stage.
Some observers may wonder whether leaving the United States for Scotland is truly a step up. The Scottish Premiership does not have the financial muscle of the Premier League, and critics sometimes question its standard. But for a player like Makhanya, the move offers several things MLS cannot.
First, there is the pressure. Rangers play for trophies every season, and expectations at the club are enormous. Every match matters, and the supporters are demanding. That kind of environment forces players to develop mentally as well as technically.
Second, there is the visibility. Scottish football is closely watched across the British game, and strong performers for Rangers and Celtic have a long record of moving on to bigger leagues. A defender who impresses at Ibrox can attract interest from England and the rest of Europe.
Third, there is the football itself. The physical, direct style of much of the Scottish game, combined with the technical demands of playing for a team expected to dominate possession, gives a defender a varied education.
Fortune’s comments reflect all three of these points, even if he put them in simpler terms. In his view, the transfer was a necessary move up, and the sort of step a player with ambition should be taking
None of this means Makhanya’s future is assured. Early praise can be fragile in football, and a strong start does not guarantee a strong season. Defenders in particular are judged harshly when results go badly, and Rangers have been through demanding periods in recent seasons.
There is also the matter of how long a player like Makhanya will stay. Some reporting around the club has already speculated about interest in him, and one outlet described a sense of concern among supporters that a good start could attract suitors quickly. That worry is understandable. Rangers have a history of developing players and then selling them, and fans are used to enjoying a talented defender for a short time before a bigger club makes an offer.
That is a problem for another day. For now, the priority is for Makhanya to keep performing and keep learning. He has handled the early challenges, including a derby, and has earned respect from people who know the game
For Rangers, Fortune’s words are a small but useful endorsement. Clubs spend a lot of money and effort on recruitment, and it is always satisfying when outsiders confirm that a signing looks like a good one. A £3 million investment in a young defender with room to grow looks, on current evidence, like sensible business.
It also reflects a recruitment approach that looks beyond the traditional markets. MLS has become an increasingly common source of talent for European clubs, and Rangers have shown they are prepared to look there when the right player is available. If Makhanya continues to develop, he could become a model for similar signings in future.
The praise comes, too, at a time when the club is trying to rebuild momentum. A run of wins, including over Celtic, and a settled back line have given the supporters reasons for optimism. Positive talk about individual players helps maintain that mood, even if the real judgement will come from results on the pitch.
Quinton Fortune’s assessment is easy to summarise. He thinks Olwethu Makhanya made the right call. He thinks Rangers is the right place for the next stage of the defender’s career. And he believes that experiences such as the Old Firm will make him a better player.
Coming from someone who won trophies at Manchester United and carried the hopes of South African football in Europe, that is a meaningful endorsement. It also carries a hopeful message for other young players back home: the road from South Africa to the big stages of European football can be travelled, and those who make the journey can help widen it for others.
Whether Makhanya goes on to become a long-term fixture at Ibrox or a stepping stone to something bigger, his first months have been encouraging. For the player, the club, and a former United man watching proudly from afar, “unbelievable” seems to be the right word







