Rangers legend explains why Frank Lampard was his preferred 2023 Ibrox managerial candidate over Clement

When Rangers parted company with Michael Beale in the autumn of 2023, the club needed a manager quickly. It also needed someone to make the process look serious. Among the people it turned to was Graeme Souness, a man who knows the Ibrox dugout better than almost anyone alive. Rangers brought Souness on board as an advisor throughout the recruitment of Beale’s replacement, but decided not to follow his recommendation of the former England midfielder.
That sentence contains the whole drama. A club legend, a high-profile English name and a Belgian coach with a strong CV: it is a story of three personalities and one decision that supporters have debated ever since.
Souness did not hide his view, and that proved controversial in its own right. It also produced one of the more interesting pieces of insight into how the Rangers board thinks. This piece goes back through what was said, what was meant, and why it still matters.
It is hard to overstate Souness’s standing at the club. He arrived in 1986 as player-manager and, at just 33 years old, he took the job on and went on to revolutionise both Rangers and Scottish football. He understood the landscape because he had lived inside it, and he understood the expectations because he had set a good number of them himself.
By the time of the 2023 search he was 70 and a regular broadcaster. Pundits can be easy to dismiss, but a man who built a successful Rangers side from the dugout is a different proposition. When he says a job has demands unlike any other, the board listens, even when it does not agree.
He was brought in because the club recognised that. The decision to involve him tells you the hierarchy wanted a sounding board who understood the institution, not just the tactics
The shortlist, as reported at the time, was not a long one. Souness has since described the contest as one between two outstanding candidates. He said there were two outstanding candidates, Frank and Philippe, and that the final say wasn’t with him. That caveat matters. He was an adviser, not the decision-maker.
On one side stood Frank Lampard, the Chelsea great whose managerial career had taken in Derby, Chelsea and Everton. Reports at the time said preliminary conversations had taken place and that Lampard was interested in heading to Ibrox. On the other stood Philippe Clement, whose CV included Beveren, Genk, Club Brugge and Monaco. Rangers described the Belgian as the outstanding candidate across all the key criteria, pointing to his track record of winning titles.
There was nothing obviously wrong with either name. That is what made the decision interesting. Neither choice was a gamble in the way some recent appointments in Scottish football have been. They were simply different kinds of risk.
So what tipped Souness towards Lampard? The answer, as he explained it publicly, came down to a combination of motivation and familiarity.
On motivation, he was struck by how much Lampard wanted the job. Souness said what encouraged him about Lampard was that he wanted to do it, that he did not need the money, and that he wanted to be a successful manager and fancied the Rangers job. That is a revealing point. Managerial roles at big clubs are often chosen for CVs, but hunger matters, and Souness read hunger in Lampard.
He also felt the former England midfielder had plenty left to give. He said Lampard still had a great deal to offer and that he would not be too critical of him. At the time, many supporters were sceptical about Lampard after a difficult period at Everton, and Souness was effectively arguing that one rough spell should not define a man.
But the part that attracted the most attention was the cultural argument. Souness suggested that Lampard’s background in British football meant he would understand the west of Scotland better than a coach arriving from continental Europe. He said Lampard’s background in British football meant he would understand the west of Scotland a bit more than Philippe.
That is a subtle point, and it is easy to caricature. He wasn’t saying Clement was unqualified. He was saying that the Rangers job is unlike a job anywhere else in football, and that familiarity with the surrounding environment can shorten the learning curve.
If Souness had a reservation about Clement, it was never about quality. He said the Belgian was an outstanding candidate, which is why the board went with him, and that he fully understood the decision. Nor did he hold back praise for how the Belgian handled the interview stage. He said Clement interviewed brilliantly, that he had presence and a very good CV, and that he played the game.
The one question mark, as he put it, was the west of Scotland football world, which he described as absolutely full-on, and how Clement would deal with it. It is a fair concern. Plenty of talented managers have found the intensity of Glasgow football, the scrutiny, the noise and the permanent expectation, harder to handle than the football itself.
It is also worth noting that Souness was quick to say the new appointment was not short of attributes either. He watched Clement’s first press conference and came away convinced. He said Clement understood the demands of the job. In other words, his reservations were about a specific risk, not a verdict on the man.
Here the story takes an interesting turn. The initial reporting framed Souness as someone who had actively lobbied for Lampard. Later, he pushed back on that. He said it wasn’t entirely true that he had been advocating for Lampard, and described the choice as a narrow thing.
That nuance is important. There is a difference between preferring one candidate by a small margin and campaigning for him. Souness appears to have been the first, not the second. The advantage he saw in Lampard was modest, a matter of cultural fit, not a conviction that Clement was the wrong choice.
It also tells you something about how these processes work. Advisers weigh candidates, discuss strengths and weaknesses, and offer a view. The board, led by chief executive James Bisgrove, then makes the call. The board, led by Bisgrove, decided to go the other way. That is how the structure is supposed to function, and Souness himself seemed comfortable with it.
There was another strand to this story, and it concerned the supporters. Few fans at the time fancied Lampard after his fraught time as Everton manager. Social media had already made up its mind, and the mood around the possibility of an English appointment was cool.
A column in the Daily Record captured the tension well. It noted that Souness would have had Lampard in the dugout if he had been given the final say, but that we will never know how Lampard would have done, and that this would go down as a win for fan power in the eyes of the support. Whether or not the board was swayed by sentiment, the perception was there.
This is a recurring tension at big clubs. Executives want to hire on merit, but they also know that a manager who starts without the fans’ goodwill faces an uphill struggle. Clement, by contrast, arrived with a clean slate and a trophy-winning résumé, and that helped
Not everyone thought it was wise for Souness to speak publicly. Former chairman Dave King criticised him for going public about his desire to bring Lampard to the club, saying he should have kept it in-house.
King’s argument was that private disagreement over a recruitment process should stay private, particularly when the man who won the job has to walk into a dressing room and a stadium carrying that public comparison. It is a reasonable point. A manager does not want to start his tenure with a club legend on the record saying he would have picked someone else. Souness might reply that he was asked a direct question and answered it honestly, and that he was consistently complimentary about Clement. Both positions have merit, and the disagreement shows how sensitive the topic was.
If Souness’s remarks made things awkward, the pitch quickly provided an answer. Clement began his tenure with a 4-0 win over Hibernian. That kind of result calms nerves and shifts a conversation.
The following months brought genuine success. Rangers won the League Cup, reached the Europa League last 16 and sat clear at the top of the league, even after a 2-1 defeat to Motherwell. The Belgian had made a strong impression on Souness too, who by then was hoping he would enjoy plenty of success at the club.
In those weeks, the board’s decision looked vindicated. The man the club had chosen was winning, and the man Souness had slightly preferred was out of work. Dave King even noted that Lampard was still without a job, and was the subject of an April Fools gag about taking over at Aberdeen.
Football narratives rarely stay tidy, though. As the season progressed, results turned. At one stage, a defeat by Aberdeen left Rangers nine points behind in the title race, and some began wondering whether Souness might have had a point. The decline continued into the following campaign. Clement was dismissed in late February, after disappointing domestic results, including humiliating home defeats to Queen’s Park and Motherwell. It was a sharp fall for a manager who had begun with a cup win and European progress.
The contrast between Europe and the league was striking. Ally McCoist said that while he had hoped Clement would be given more time after the European run, it was clear why he was sacked given the domestic form. The picture was one of a manager who could produce moments but not consistency.
Barry Ferguson, a name familiar to readers of the earlier Lewis Ferguson story, took over on an interim basis. His notable achievement was guiding Rangers to a 3-1 away win over Fenerbahce in the Europa League round of 16. It was a reminder of how much Ferguson family history is woven through the club’s recent story.
With Clement gone, another club icon weighed in. Ally McCoist said Rangers should have gone for Frank Lampard before he went to Coventry. He went further, comparing the approach to the Steven Gerrard appointment, suggesting Lampard could have arrived with the same hunger to succeed.
McCoist’s view added weight to Souness’s earlier preference. Two of the club’s most recognisable figures, from different eras, had independently suggested the board missed an opportunity. The reporting noted that Lampard was also doing well at Coventry City, where he had found his feet. That success made the debate more pointed. The man who had been passed over was proving himself elsewhere.
It is worth being careful here. Hindsight is a flattering lens. We know that Lampard thrived at Coventry, but we cannot know whether he would have thrived at Rangers. The two environments are not comparable. Managing in the Championship is not managing in Glasgow, with the weight of the Old Firm and a fan base that demands trophies, not progress.
This is the question that sits underneath the whole story. Did Rangers get it wrong?
The case that they did rests on the cultural argument. Souness believed British football experience would help a coach navigate the west of Scotland, and the club’s decline under Clement could be read as proof that the environment overwhelmed him. McCoist’s comments lend support to that view.
The case that they did not rests on the fact that the process was rigorous, and that the choice was defensible on merit. The club said Clement proved to be the outstanding candidate across all the key criteria. His early results, including a trophy and a European run, suggested the call was sound. And as Souness himself admitted, it was a narrow decision between two strong candidates.
The honest answer is probably that it was a reasonable decision that did not work out as hoped. That is not the same as a wrong decision. Appointments are probabilistic. Even the best-run processes produce failures, because football is volatile and managers rise and fall for reasons that have little to do with how they interview
First, cultural fit matters more at some clubs than others. Rangers and Celtic operate in an environment unlike almost anywhere else in European football. Souness has said many times that it is a unique job, and that the same must be true for Celtic. A manager’s tactical ability is necessary but not sufficient. Handling the scrutiny, the history and the demands is a skill in itself.
Second, the role of advisers is delicate. Bringing in a legend can lend credibility and insight, but it also creates a public record of disagreement. Clubs that involve figures like Souness should be prepared for the possibility that they will speak candidly later. Third, fan sentiment is real but unreliable. Supporters were cool on Lampard, and the board may have taken that into account. But supporters are poor predictors of managerial success, and sentiment can flip quickly in either direction. The same fans who doubted Lampard would later hear his name raised in the Ibrox conversation.
The story of the 2023 search is, in the end, a story about uncertainty. Souness leaned one way by a narrow margin. The board went the other. The decision produced a trophy, a European run and then a painful decline.
As the club has moved on, other names have taken the dugout, and the conversation has changed. Anyone writing about the current situation should check the latest position, since managerial news can shift within days. What will endure is the lesson of that October: that the best choice on paper is not always the best choice in practice, and that the Rangers job has a way of exposing every assumption made about it.
Souness, characteristically, did not claim vindication. He said the decision was narrow, praised the man who got the job and accepted that the final say belonged to others. It is a more measured stance than headlines suggested at the time, and perhaps a more honest one. Whether Lampard would have succeeded at Ibrox is one of those questions that can never be answered. That is exactly why it keeps being asked








