Why McInnes Should Bench Kim and Unleash Rangers’ New Ryan Kent

Every manager reaches a point in the season where the safe choice and the right choice pull in different directions. Derek McInnes has reached it on the left side of his attack. The safe choice is to keep faith with a record signing who has made a promising impression. The right choice, I’d argue, is to give a hungry academy graduate a start against St Mirren and see whether Rangers have found something they have been missing since a certain English winger left Ibrox.
This is an opinion piece, so I should be clear about what it rests on. The central argument comes from a FootballFanCast opinion article published today, which suggests that Findlay Curtis could replace Minsu Kim in the starting line-up and become Rangers’ new Ryan Kent. I have built my own case on that idea, using reporting from other outlets to test it, and I have tried to give the counterarguments a fair hearing. I do not have detailed statistics on Curtis’s season, so I have kept that part qualitative.
Start with the immediate context. The suggestion is that McInnes could drop Kim to the bench. He started on the left side of the attack last weekend and struggled to make an impact in the final third. That is the nub of the problem. Kim is a talented player, but wide attackers are judged by what they produce in the last third: goals, assists, chances created, the ability to turn a possession into a threat. When that output dries up, even a good performer becomes vulnerable.
There is also a practical angle. A game on the bench before the international break could be a good chance for Kim to reset and be ready to get back to his best after playing for his country. I like that framing because it removes any sense of punishment. Resting a player before an international window is standard management. It protects him physically and gives him a mental break, and it does so at a moment when the fixture list offers a natural pause. There is no real cost to doing it
Who steps in? The answer proposed is Curtis. The Ibrox academy graduate has Kent-esque potential, given what he has already shown as a scorer and a creator at Premiership level. That combination is what makes the comparison interesting. Plenty of young wingers can dribble. Far fewer can both score and create, and fewer still have shown it in the league against real opposition. That dual threat is exactly what defined Kent at his best.
It helps to remember what Kent actually gave Rangers, because the comparison is a demanding one. He racked up 56 assists in 218 appearances in all competitions, including 21 assists across his last two league seasons with the club. That is not a headline-grabbing return in the way a striker’s goals might be, but it is consistent, dependable creativity. Kent was a player who could be trusted to provide the final ball, to stretch defences and to arrive in the right place. Rangers have missed that quality, and supporters know it.
The need for it is plain. Several opinion writers have made the same observation about the current team. Adding more creativity to the team is where McInnes most needs to improve his side. That line was written in the context of a different match, but the logic applies here. Rangers can defend, they can work hard, and they have recently put together a run of results. What they sometimes lack is a spark, someone who can unlock a stubborn defence when the game is tight.
The recent record shows why caution is tempting. Rangers have started the 2026/27 campaign strongly under McInnes, scoring in each of their last ten matches, and that run has given the manager a settled attacking unit. Managers are reluctant to change a winning team, and that instinct is sound. Disrupting a settled side carries risk, and a run of ten consecutive games with a goal suggests the machine is working. Anyone arguing for a change has to explain why it is worth the gamble.
My answer is that this is exactly the right moment for a measured one. St Mirren at home is the kind of fixture where a young player can be introduced with limited downside. Rangers are expected to win, and the occasion carries less pressure than a derby or a European night. If Curtis delivers, the team benefits. If he struggles, there is a deep bench to turn to and the match is unlikely to hinge on one selection.
Consider also the arguments for Kim, because he deserves them. He cost real money. Rangers reportedly paid £8.5 million to sign the South Korean attacker from Girona. A fee like that creates expectations, and the player has often justified them. After the win over St Johnstone, pundits agreed that his best position is on the left wing, where he supplied the pass for Ryan Naderi’s opener and was involved in all three goals. That is a strong endorsement, and it came only recently.
There is a case that his value goes beyond the numbers. Rangers Review argued that his impact on the club’s resurgence exceeds his current statistics, making him McInnes’ best tactical option. I take that seriously. Statistics do not capture everything. A winger who draws defenders, creates space for others and links play may contribute more than his goals and assists suggest. Anyone who watches football closely knows that some of the most useful players leave little trace in the data
Another analysis points to what Kim offers the manager in particular. He offers the direct runs and defensive work the manager wants. McInnes is a coach who values structure and commitment, and Kim ticks those boxes. If this were simply a question of who suits the manager’s style, the answer might well be Kim. But that is precisely why a change could be useful. A team that relies on one type of wide player becomes predictable. Introducing a different profile forces opponents to adjust.
This is where Curtis come in. His style is not a carbon copy of Kim’s. He is more of a creator, a player who looks for the pass and the space between the lines. Against a side like St Mirren, who are likely to sit deep and defend in numbers, that kind of invention can be the difference between a frustrating draw and a comfortable win. Rangers have struggled at times against compact defences, and a creative left-sided player is the sort of solution a manager should want to test.
The squad dynamics matter too. Curtis is currently the subject of another debate. Rangers face a January decision on whether to loan him to a Premiership rival, because keeping him on the bench does little for his development or his Scotland prospects. That argument is persuasive, and it carries a corollary: if Rangers are considering sending him out to gain minutes, they should at least find out whether he can offer those minutes at Ibrox first. Starting him against St Mirren is a low-risk way of answering the question
It would also send a message to the rest of the squad. Players who train hard and wait patiently need to see that opportunities exist. A manager who rewards form and potential, not just reputation, builds a healthier dressing room. If Kim has an off week and Curtis steps in and performs, that competition raises standards across the squad. If instead the manager always picks the same eleven, those on the bench lose motivation
Look, too, at the wider picture on the flanks. Kim and Badredine Bouanani are both proficient dribblers, so Rangers no longer need to rely on Djeidi Gassama as the only outlet to progress the play. That observation was made in the context of a different argument about Gassama’s goalscoring record, but it highlights something important. Rangers have options. The days of relying on one wide player to carry the creative burden are over. That abundance is a luxury, and it gives McInnes room to experiment.
Gassama’s situation is a useful comparison. Commentators have noted that he has not scored in nine games despite his work rate and ball-carrying. What frustrates, much as with Kent, is not his work rate or attitude but his goal return. That is the Kent comparison in a nutshell. A winger can do many things right and still be judged harshly if the end product is missing. It is also why Curtis’s reputation as someone who both scores and creates is so appealing. He may offer the productive output that supporters want.
Let me be honest about the risks. Curtis is young, and young players are inconsistent. A strong debut or a good cameo does not guarantee a regular place. He might struggle with the physical demands of a full ninety minutes, or with the tactical responsibilities McInnes demands. The comparison with Kent is also, by definition, aspirational. Kent was an established Premiership performer for years, and expecting a youngster to match that is unfair. The best-case scenario is that Curtis becomes a valuable player, not necessarily a replica.
There is also the matter of trust. Managers build trust slowly, through training sessions, small decisions and consistent performance. If McInnes does not yet trust Curtis defensively, starting him could feel like a risk. That is a legitimate concern, and only the manager knows the answer. But it is worth asking how trust is built if players are never given the chance. A start against St Mirren is a sensible way to begin.
Timing strengthens the argument. Kim is about to join up with his national team, and there will be a natural break in the club schedule. Resting him now allows him to come back refreshed. Starting Curtis, meanwhile, gives the coaching staff a chance to assess him in a real match without the pressure of a must-win fixture. It is a win-win scenario, which is rare in football management.
There is one more point in favour. Rangers supporters are, for the most part, hungry for something new. The team has been winning, but results have not always been convincing, and fans are looking for signs of progress and excitement. A young academy product starting a league match is the kind of storyline that lifts a stadium. It connects the crowd to the club’s own development system and gives them a player to get behind. That emotional dimension matters, even if it is hard to quantify.
The history of the academy at Ibrox is part of this story. Rangers have often struggled to turn young talent into regular first-team players, and each new graduate who breaks through is greeted with hope. When it works, the benefits are enormous: lower costs, stronger bonds with supporters and a pipeline of players who understand the club’s culture. When it does not, the result is frustration. Every opportunity given to a young player is a small investment in the club’s long-term health.
What would success look like against St Mirren? I would not expect a hat-trick or a man-of-the-match performance. A solid, confident display with a couple of chances created and an assist or goal would be enough. The aim is to show that Curtis can play at this level consistently, not just in occasional bursts. If he can do that, the case for more minutes becomes irresistible.
If it goes badly, the damage is limited. Kim would return to the side after the break, perhaps with renewed energy, and the manager would have learned something about the squad. Experimentation is part of the job, and a defeat or a drawn game against an average opponent is not a catastrophe in a long season. The upside, on the other hand, could be significant.
There is a broader philosophical point here about squad management. Great managers are those who can balance continuity with change, knowing when to stick and when to twist. McInnes has shown a pragmatic streak throughout his career, and this feels like an ideal moment to exercise it. The team is in decent form, the fixtures are manageable and the squad has depth. If he is ever going to try something different, now is the time.
None of this means that Kim is a failure or that Curtis is a guaranteed star. Both are talented, and both will probably play significant roles this season. The argument is simply that for this match, in these circumstances, the balance of risk and reward favours giving the younger player his chance. Football is a game of marginal gains, and sometimes the most valuable decisions are the small ones that others overlook.
In the end, supporters will judge McInnes on results, not on selection theories. If Rangers win comfortably and Curtis plays well, the decision will look inspired. If they stumble, critics will say he overthought it. That is the nature of the job. But the reasoning is sound, the circumstances are favourable and the potential benefits are clear. A creative, goal-scoring winger from the academy would be a huge asset, and the only way to find out whether Curtis can be that player is to let him start.
So start him today. Rest Kim, let him recover and refocus, and hand the left side to the young player who has already shown flashes of the quality Rangers need. If he is anything like the player his admirers believe, the new Ryan Kent may not be warming the bench for much longer.
The core idea (Curtis starting over Kim against St Mirren, as a replacement for Kim’s lack of end product) comes from the FootballFanCast article. I wasn’t able to open its full text, so my paragraphs on the counterarguments, the risks and the squad dynamics are my own analysis, drawing on other reports. I don’t have Curtis’s exact statistics, which is why none appear. Check the St Mirren fixture details and today’s team news before publishing, since the lineup may already be out. If you want a harder, more punchy opinion tone or a shorter version, I can adjust it.







